Skipper's Seafood Restaurant
seafood★ 4.3(268)
Family-owned seafood shack on Main Street that has been frying and steaming since 2003. The lobster rolls are stuffed and served warm with drawn butter or cold with mayo, and the clam strips are consistently golden and greaseless. No pretense, counter ordering, picnic tables — this is classic New England shore food done right.
3 local tips
- The hot lobster roll with drawn butter is the move here; ask for it split and toasted on a New England-style top-loader.
- Lines form fast on summer weekends — arrive before noon or after 2pm to skip the worst of the wait.
- Clam chowder sells out; if you want a cup, order it first thing before it's gone by early afternoon.
Dad's Restaurant of Niantic
seafood★ 4.2(138)
A Niantic institution since 1963, Dad's serves fried whole-belly clams, lobster rolls, fish and chips, and burgers from a casual dining room with indoor and outdoor seating steps from Niantic Bay. New owners took over the Main Street landmark and reopened it in 2025 after a renovation, keeping the familiar shore-food menu and the waterfront setting that locals have relied on for more than sixty years.
3 local tips
- Whole-belly clams are the signature — skip the strips and go for the real thing with a side of tartar sauce.
- Ask for a table on the water side; the dining room and patio look straight out over Niantic Bay.
- Parking is tight on Main Street in summer, so the municipal lot behind the block is your best bet.
Flanders Fish Market & Restaurant
seafood★ 4.4(693)
Connecticut's premier seafood market and restaurant, family-owned since 1983 and awarded Best Seafood by Connecticut Magazine multiple times. The working retail fish counter up front transitions to a full dining room and outdoor patio where you can order the same day's catch as a plate. The lobster pot pie won a Rachel Ray Magazine award and is worth ordering even in July.
3 local tips
- Buy from the market counter to take raw fish back if you have a kitchen — the selection and quality rival anything in New London County.
- The outdoor patio books up on Friday and Saturday evenings; call ahead or arrive early in the week.
- They do full custom clambakes for groups — ask at the counter if you're planning a beach gathering.
374 Kitchen & Cocktails
american★ 4.2(120)
Niantic's most polished dinner spot, occupying a converted space at the north end of Main Street. The menu leans elevated comfort food — think craft-beer-braised short ribs, locally sourced fish of the day, and house-made pasta — paired with creative cocktails and a curated Connecticut tap list. The vibe is lively without being loud.
3 local tips
- Book a table on OpenTable for Friday and Saturday evenings — it fills up fast and walk-in waits can exceed an hour in summer.
- The craft cocktail list changes seasonally; ask the bartender what's new rather than defaulting to the printed menu.
- Sitting at the bar is a solid option if you're solo or a couple and want a quicker turnaround.
Castello of Niantic
italian★ 4.3(104)
Warm, family-owned Italian restaurant tucked just off the main drag on East Pattagansett Road. Homemade pasta, classic red-sauce dishes, and a rotating seafood special are the draws here, along with a seasonal patio that fills up on warm evenings. Nothing pretentious — just straightforward Italian cooking that Niantic regulars have been counting on for years.
3 local tips
- The homemade gnocchi and baked ziti are standout dishes; ask the server what the kitchen is proud of that night.
- The patio is first-come and fills by 6pm on weekends — dine early or plan to sit inside.
- They do catering for events; worth knowing if you're hosting a larger group gathering.
The Spice Club
asian★ 4.0(211)
Asian fusion restaurant on the Niantic waterfront serving Thai, Japanese, Chinese, and sushi under one roof since 2012. The menu is unusually wide — pad Thai, sushi rolls, bao, and stir-fries — and the kitchen accommodates vegan and vegetarian diets more thoughtfully than most places in the area. Full bar and a view of the bay.
3 local tips
- The Thai curries and the specialty sushi rolls are the strongest parts of the menu — don't try to order one of everything.
- Waterfront table seating is limited; ask specifically for a bay-view spot when you reserve.
- They open seven days a week, making it a reliable option when other spots are closed on Mondays.
Giuliano's Bakery
cafe★ 4.5(180)
A true neighborhood bakery on Main Street baking bagels, muffins, croissants, and egg sandwiches from early morning, plus award-winning grinders that have a cult following among locals. The cases rotate with seasonal pastries, and everything is made on-site. This is where the town shows up before hitting the beach.
3 local tips
- The breakfast sandwiches sell fast — arrive before 9am on weekends to guarantee your choice.
- Ask about the grinder of the day; their Italian and turkey clubs have won local 'best of' awards repeatedly.
- Coffee and a pastry on the sidewalk bench is the ideal low-key Niantic morning.
GG at Home
brunch★ 4.4(150)
A full-service cafe and eatery at 185 Main Street with waterfront views of Niantic Bay. The made-to-order menu covers breakfast, lunch, and light dinner with locally sourced ingredients, and the charming interior spills onto a patio with one of the better water views on the strip. Popular with working-from-the-shore types and post-boardwalk brunchers.
3 local tips
- Come for the view as much as the food — get a patio table and linger over an iced coffee after your boardwalk walk.
- The seasonal specials board changes weekly; worth asking what's fresh before defaulting to the regular menu.
- Parking is easier here than at the southern end of Main Street — the small lot out front usually has space.
Niantic Public House & Brewery
american★ 4.3(130)
Niantic's only craft brewery, pouring 22 house beers and two ciders on tap in a taproom painted floor-to-ceiling with undersea murals. The IPAs and seasonal ales are made on-site, and guest taps rotate through other Connecticut and New England breweries. Flights are the way to go, and the space is genuinely relaxed — no hustle, just good pours.
3 local tips
- Order a flight of four to five before committing to a pint — the style range is wide and the bartenders will guide you.
- The taproom is cash and card, but the atmosphere is resolutely no-pretense; bring your own snacks if you're staying a while.
- Check their Instagram for seasonal release days — limited batches sell out quickly.