The Stilt House
american★ 4.2(475)
A gastropub in a genuinely historic building — the original tavern was raised on stilts when the owner needed a first floor below it — now pouring 30 rotating taps and serving a small-plate menu that changes with the season. The tuna tartare and shrimp tacos have devoted regulars, and the outdoor patio fills fast on warm evenings. Beer selection leans heavily toward Wisconsin craft with some well-chosen imports.
3 local tips
- The small plates are sized for sharing two or three between two people — don't over-order
- The covered patio is heated in shoulder season; ask about it before sitting inside
- Rotating tap handles mean something interesting is almost always on; ask what's new before ordering
Anvil Pub & Grille
american★ 4.2(469)
Set in the Cedar Creek Settlement's restored 19th-century blacksmith's shop, with exposed stone walls and a creek-side patio that overlooks the Cedar Creek waterfall, this is the closest thing Cedarburg has to a neighborhood anchor. The menu is pub-honest — steak burgers, stone-hearth Forge sandwiches, and a Friday fish fry in a light, crisp batter — and the waterfall seating in good weather is genuinely pleasant. The room itself, all quarried stone and low timber, does a lot of the work.
3 local tips
- The creek-side patio overlooks the Cedar Creek waterfall — worth waiting for a table there in warm weather
- Friday fish fry draws a line by 6pm — arrive early or eat late
- The building was the Settlement's blacksmith shop — the original stonework and timber beams are still overhead
Tomaso's Italian Kitchen
italian★ 3.9(208)
A family-owned pizzeria on Washington Avenue that has been feeding Cedarburg since 1976, long enough to have regulars who now bring their own kids. The draw is the pizza — a thin, cracker-crisp crust or a deep dish, both built with the cheese tucked under the sauce and toppings — backed by spaghetti, ravioli, and sandwiches. You order at the bar and seat yourself, and it gets crowded on weekends.
3 local tips
- The thin, cracker-crisp crust is the signature order — the cheese-under-sauce build is what keeps it crisp
- Takeout works well here — the food travels without losing much
- Weeknight dinner is calmer than weekends; easier to get a table and have a conversation
Cream & Crepe Cafe
cafe★ 4.3(180)
A downtown cafe that does both savory and sweet crepes well, along with soups that change daily and coffee that's taken seriously. The broccoli cream soup and savory crepes are the reliables; the dessert crepes are worth finishing with. Seating is tight but the staff moves efficiently and it doesn't feel rushed.
3 local tips
- The daily soup is often the best thing on the menu — ask before ordering
- Savory crepes are a full meal; the sweet ones are better split between two people
- Midmorning on weekdays is the calmest time to go
Rebellion Brewing Company
american★ 4.3(194)
A brewpub occupying part of the 1855 limestone grist mill that predates even Cedar Creek Settlement, with a beer garden overlooking the creek. The beer program runs from clean lagers to experimental small-batch releases, and the food is more than an afterthought. The setting — old mill stone, creek sounds, hop aromas — is as good as it gets in Cedarburg.
3 local tips
- The creek-facing beer garden is the main draw in warm weather; the indoor space is fine but less special
- Ask about limited tapping days for specialty batches — they sell out quickly
- The mill's original stone foundation is visible through a glass floor section inside
The Fermentorium Brewery & Tasting Room
american★ 4.4(320)
A larger craft brewery just south of downtown with 24 taps covering the range from crisp session ales to aggressive IPAs and stouts, in a comfortable tasting room with good natural light and ample seating. The food program is solid enough to make this a full stop rather than a quick pint. Less atmospheric than the mill breweries but more consistent in volume and variety.
3 local tips
- The tap list rotates fast; the online menu is usually current if you want to plan ahead
- The in-house kitchen turns out gourmet hot dogs, pizzas, and shareable plates — no need to plan around a food truck
- The outdoor area fills with families on weekends afternoons; the inside is calmer
Maxwell's
american★ 3.7(65)
The neighborhood tavern that Cedarburg regulars actually go to — no pretense, reliable bar food, and a Friday fish fry that draws a line out the door. The beer list is straightforward and the cocktails are what you'd expect from a Wisconsin bar that's been doing this since the 1980s. Come for the fish fry or come for a no-fuss lunch; don't come expecting anything it isn't.
3 local tips
- Friday fish fry is the reason to be here; arrive before 5:30 or wait
- The daily specials board often beats the printed menu on value
- Cash is appreciated; the service is fast and no-nonsense
Union House
american★ 4.0(90)
An intimate Washington Avenue spot focused on small shareable plates — cheese boards, crostini, roasted vegetables — alongside a wine and cocktail list that's more considered than the room's casual feel suggests. The charcuterie selection is sourced carefully and the accompaniments change with the season. Better for a slow drink-and-graze than a quick meal.
3 local tips
- Order the cheese board as an anchor and build around it with two or three small plates
- The cocktail list is short but well-made; ask for the bartender's current preference
- The space is small and fills on Friday and Saturday evenings; reservations help