Joanie's Pizzeria of Long Grove
american★ 4.5(486)
A family-run pizzeria on Robert Parker Coffin Road doing Detroit-style squares with a properly caramelized edge alongside broasted chicken that regulars consider the kitchen's real signature. The dining room is casual and owner-operated, with the kind of attention to the room you get when someone actually cares who's eating there.
3 local tips
- The broasted chicken is a separate order from the pizza and worth adding even if you came for the pie — regulars often rate it higher.
- Detroit-style pies take time to build; if you're on a schedule, call ahead or order the thin crust for a faster table.
- Weeknight dinners are calmer and the kitchen runs faster; Friday evenings get busy.
Enzo & Lucia Ristorante Italiano
italian★ 4.2(321)
Italian-American trattoria in a 19th-century Victorian farmhouse on Old McHenry Road, with a long-standing reputation for handmade cappellacci stuffed with seasonal fillings. The wraparound porch patio is one of the nicest outdoor settings in Long Grove — close enough to downtown to walk, far enough to feel quieter on a summer evening.
3 local tips
- The pasta menu changes seasonally; ask the server what's housemade that week rather than defaulting to the printed specials.
- Weekend reservations fill about a week out; Tuesday and Wednesday evenings are easier to walk into.
- The eggplant parmigiana is a consistent crowd favorite worth ordering alongside rather than instead of the pasta.
Chatter Box of Long Grove
american★ 4.4(360)
A converted dairy barn turned gastropub on Old McHenry Road with exposed beams, a solid tap list, and scratch-made bar food that consistently outperforms typical pub fare. The Reuben egg rolls and bacon-wrapped dates have a cult following, and the Old Fashioned program is taken seriously. Live music on weekends makes it the most energetic room in Long Grove after dark.
3 local tips
- The downstairs bar area operates separately from the upstairs dining room — if you have children, ask the host to seat you upstairs.
- Taco Tuesday is popular for the price, but the regular menu is the stronger eat.
- Arrive before 6:30 on live music nights for a seat near the stage without a wait.
Blu Fig Cafe
cafe★ 4.6(102)
A compact morning-and-lunch cafe on Robert Parker Coffin Road doing bagels, gourmet sandwiches, and specialty coffee in a warm 20-seat European-style room. Baked goods are made in-house daily and sell out by early afternoon. The best breakfast option within walking distance of the covered bridge.
3 local tips
- Get there before noon if you want pastries — croissants and cookies are typically gone by 1pm.
- The Plant Power sandwich and lox bagel are the two items regulars reorder most.
- Parking in front fills fast on weekends; the side lot off the alley usually has space.
Corked Restaurant and Wine Bar
mediterranean★ 4.7(54)
A wine-forward room in the historic district with an international bottle list, charcuterie, Spanish conservas (tinned fish), and a small menu of salads, sandwiches, and steaks. The heated patio with string lights is one of the more pleasant spots in Long Grove on a cool evening — the staff know their wines well enough to make recommendations worth following.
3 local tips
- The Spanish conservas board is an underrated starter that most tables skip in favor of cheese — worth trying.
- The grassy lawn area works well for groups wanting to spread out; call ahead for parties over four.
- The wine-by-the-glass list rotates; ask what's open that night rather than defaulting to the printed menu.
Sorelle Italian Kitchen and Market
italian★ 4.5(144)
An Italian street food counter and wine market on Route 22 that pivots to dinner service in the evenings — housemade pastas, imported pantry goods, and a short natural wine list in an unpretentious room. It fills the gap between casual Italian-American and the fancier trattoria scene; the value is genuinely good for what you get.
3 local tips
- The dinner-only evening hours mean it's easy to miss assuming it's a daytime market — check current service hours before heading out.
- The market shelves stock imported Italian pantry items worth picking up even if you're just stopping for coffee.
- Small enough that walk-ins are usually fine on weeknights; weekends fill faster.
The Village Tavern
american★ 4.2(198)
Long Grove's oldest bar, operating in the same Old McHenry Road building since the mid-19th century. The Friday fish fry draws a loyal local crowd distinct from the weekend village visitors, live music fills the room on weekends, and the broasted chicken has a following that competes with Joanie's around the corner. More neighborhood institution than destination restaurant.
3 local tips
- The Friday fish fry is hand-breaded and arrives from a kitchen that's been running the same recipe for years — arrive before 6pm to beat the wait.
- Live music nights bring a livelier energy; check their social feed for the current schedule before going.
- The outdoor patio on the side of the building is the best seat in warm weather.
North Point Kitchen + Bar
american★ 4.8(132)
An Italian-influenced seasonal kitchen on the north point of Forest Lake in Lake Zurich, with a patio directly overlooking the water — one of the few genuinely lakefront dining spots in the area. The menu leans on local seasonal produce with housemade pastas, and the smashburger is a consistent staff and regular favorite. The outdoor setting makes it the better choice on any warm evening.
3 local tips
- The lakefront patio fills by 6pm on weekends; a reservation specifically requesting a water-facing table is worth making.
- The hot honey chicken sandwich is a lunch standout that gets less attention than the dinner menu deserves.
- About 10 minutes east of Long Grove on Route 22 — easy to pair with a morning in the historic district.
Tacos Guanajuato
mexican★ 4.3(373)
A compact Mexican street-food counter in Kildeer doing al pastor, shrimp, fish, and bacon-chorizo tacos with housemade salsas and a margarita list that earns equal attention. Small room, high demand, but the turnover is fast enough that waits don't drag.
3 local tips
- The mignón guacamole is made to order and takes a few minutes — order it first so it arrives while you settle in.
- The specialty margaritas read lighter than they are; one at lunch is usually the right call.
- If a wait is forming, put your name in and browse the surrounding area until called.
Pizzeria DeVille
italian★ 4.5(297)
A downtown Libertyville pizza institution doing creative pies with well-charred crusts and produce-forward toppings — roasted vegetables, unusual cheese combinations, and salads worth ordering on their own. The room is lively without being loud, and the service has a consistent track record. A cut above the standard suburban pizza operation.
3 local tips
- The roasted vegetable and goat cheese combinations are the kitchen's strength — lean toward the specialty pies over build-your-own.
- OpenTable reservations on weekends are worth making; the dining room fills by 7pm.
- Located about 12 minutes north of Long Grove on Milwaukee Avenue in downtown Libertyville.
The Green Room of Libertyville
american★ 4.5(286)
An intimate dinner-only room in downtown Libertyville with internationally influenced small plates, thoughtful seasonal mains, and a well-curated craft beer and wine list. The menu rotates frequently, drawing locals from across Lake County for the cooking rather than the ambiance — a narrow, eccentric space that would be an afterthought anywhere else.
3 local tips
- The entry has steps and is not wheelchair accessible; bathrooms are a full flight down.
- The mushroom dishes and any fresh seafood special are consistently the kitchen's strongest moves.
- Dinner only, closed Sunday and Monday; reservations recommended for weekends.
Chicago Galbi House
asian★ 4.8(150)
A Korean BBQ spot in Buffalo Grove where table-top grilling is done properly — well-marinated short ribs, quality beef, fresh banchan, and staff who pay attention to when the grill needs changing. One of the few legitimate Korean BBQ operations in the Chicago northwest suburbs, treated by locals as a regular rather than a novelty.
3 local tips
- Order the galbi (short rib) as the centerpiece and let the banchan variety guide you through the meal — don't rush the grilling.
- The ventilation is solid but avoid heavy outerwear you'd mind smelling like smoke.
- Reservations are a good idea on Friday and Saturday evenings; walk-in waits can stretch to 30 minutes.
Pita W Shawarma
middle_eastern★ 4.4(120)
A small but serious Middle Eastern counter in Buffalo Grove doing shawarma, falafel, and kabob plates with housemade garlic sauce that regulars cite as the main reason they return. Portions are generous and prices are reasonable — a no-fuss lunch or dinner that fills the gap for Middle Eastern food without driving into Chicago.
3 local tips
- The garlic sauce is the defining element of the menu — ask for extra with any order.
- The chicken shawarma plate with rice and salad is the most complete meal; the sandwich version is better for casual eating.
- Located on McHenry Road in Buffalo Grove, about 10 minutes west of Long Grove.
Aroma Fine Indian Cuisine
indian★ 4.2(276)
A well-regarded Indian kitchen in Hawthorn Village Commons in Vernon Hills, with a lunch buffet that draws a serious weekday crowd and a dinner menu that goes beyond the tikka masala circuit into more regional territory. The biriyani and seafood preparations get consistent praise from South Asian diners — a reliable signal of authenticity.
3 local tips
- The lunch buffet is a strong value and cycles dishes frequently enough that repeat visits don't feel repetitive.
- The dinner menu goes deeper into regional styles than the buffet shows — ask the server about off-menu or daily preparations.
- About 15 minutes southeast of Long Grove; the parking structure behind the commons makes access easier.
Flambé India - Libertyville
indian★ 4.7(136)
An Indian kitchen in Libertyville with a subtle French presentation influence — authentically spiced but plated with more care than the typical suburban Indian buffet. The lamb and seafood dishes are the kitchen's strong suit, and the calm room is suited for a proper dinner conversation rather than a noisy group meal.
3 local tips
- Ask about the lamb preparations; the kitchen does several regional styles and the server can walk you through what's freshest.
- The lunch thali is a good intro if you're unfamiliar with the menu — several preparations in smaller portions.
- Located on Peterson Road in Libertyville, about 14 minutes north of Long Grove.