Side Street Cafe
seafood★ 4.4(4,608)
A relaxed, year-round downtown spot that locals lean on in a town crowded with cruise-ship traffic, known for its lobster mac and cheese and a generous lobster roll. House-infused cocktails and a covered patio round out the appeal. Good for groups wanting reliable Maine comfort food without white-tablecloth prices.
3 local tips
- Put your name in early on summer evenings; the wait builds fast after 6pm
- The lobster mac and cheese is the order people come back for
- Happy hour at the bar is the locals' move for a cheaper visit
A long-running Bar Harbor fine-dining room pairing Maine ingredients with pan-Latin technique, with a wine program that has earned national recognition. Seafood paella and the mojitos are signatures. Best for a celebratory dinner where you want something beyond a lobster shack.
3 local tips
- Reserve well ahead in July and August; walk-ins face long waits
- Ask about the wine pairings, which the staff handles seriously
- Request a table away from the front door for a quieter meal
Thurston's Lobster Pound
seafood★ 4.5(1,670)
A classic order-at-the-window lobster pound on the working waterfront in Bernard, on MDI's quiet southwest side, where you watch boats unload while you eat. Steamed lobster, crab rolls, and blueberry desserts on a covered two-level deck. The choice for an unfussy, scenic lobster meal away from downtown crowds.
3 local tips
- About a 30-minute drive from Bar Harbor; combine with a Bass Harbor Head Light stop
- Seasonal operation, roughly late May through mid-October
- Go for a late lunch to avoid the dinner rush on the deck
Galyn's
american★ 4.3(3,277)
A Bar Harbor mainstay since 1986 serving straightforward seafood, chops, and chicken in a multi-level building a block from the water. Hand-crafted cocktails and a steady kitchen keep it dependable across decades. Good for a sit-down dinner when you want range beyond pure lobster.
3 local tips
- Ask for an upstairs table for partial harbor views
- It books up around sunset in peak season; reserve ahead
- A solid rainy-day fallback when patio spots are full
Rosalie's Pizza
italian★ 4.2(1,343)
A family-run Cottage Street pizzeria operating since 1981, serving New York-style pies in a casual sit-down room with an old-school feel. Order at the counter, grab a booth, and the family has run it for over 40 years. Good for a budget family dinner or takeout after a long hiking day.
3 local tips
- Cash-friendly and counter-service; expect a line at peak dinner hours
- Whole pies take time on busy nights, so call ahead for takeout
- Bring kids; it is one of the more affordable downtown options
Cafe This Way
brunch★ 4.5(2,954)
A tucked-away breakfast and dinner spot off Mount Desert Street with a bookish, garden-side feel and a reputation for pancakes and egg dishes. Locals point newcomers here for breakfast over the busier corner cafes. Good for a leisurely morning before heading into Acadia.
3 local tips
- Breakfast draws a line by 8:30am in summer; arrive early
- It also serves a well-regarded dinner that is quieter than breakfast
- The eggs Benedict and pancakes are the standout morning orders
Salsa Verde Grill
mexican★ 4.6(20)
A family-owned, New Mexico-inspired kitchen opened by a chef family that relocated from Los Angeles, bringing chile-forward tacos and plates to a seafood-heavy town. A welcome non-lobster option on Main Street. Good for a casual change of pace mid-trip.
3 local tips
- Smaller spot; expect a short wait at peak dinner times
- Ask about the green chile heat level before ordering
- A good lighter lunch between Acadia hikes
McKay's Public House
american★ 4.1(1,549)
A gastropub in a converted Victorian house downtown serving surf-and-turf fare with global touches, with a garden patio and a proper bar. Year-round operation makes it a reliable shoulder-season pick. Good for a date-night dinner that is dressier than a lobster shack but not stiff.
3 local tips
- The back garden patio is the seat to request in good weather
- Open year-round, useful in spring and fall when many spots close
- Reserve on weekends; the dining rooms are small
Jordan Pond House
american★ 3.9(3,102)
The only restaurant inside Acadia, known for popovers with strawberry jam and tea served on a lawn looking out at The Bubbles. The setting, not fine dining, is the reason to come; expect crowds and a tradition older than a century. Good for pairing with a Jordan Pond Path walk.
3 local tips
- Reservations are essential in summer and open online ahead of time
- Go for afternoon tea and popovers rather than a full meal
- Pair it with the flat 3.3-mile Jordan Pond Path loop next door
Mount Dessert Bakery
cafe★ 4.8(111)
A locally owned cafe and bakery in the heart of downtown turning out fresh pastries, sandwiches, and Maine-roasted coffee and espresso. A practical grab-and-go before an early Acadia start. Good for trail snacks and a fast caffeine fix.
3 local tips
- Open early; useful for a Cadillac sunrise coffee run
- Grab sandwiches here to pack for a midday trail lunch
- Limited seating, so plan to take it to go in peak season
A Slice of Eden
cafe★ 4.7(128)
A small from-scratch bakery and cafe on Cottage Street turning out fresh bagels, pastries, and sandwiches a block off the Main Street bustle, with a cramped, kitschy room to wait in. Blueberry crumble pie and Pain au Chocolat are the draws, and vegan bagels and spreads are on hand. Good for a quick breakfast pastry or a packed lunch before heading into Acadia.
3 local tips
- The small fresh-baked bagels sell through in the morning, so come early
- Seating is very limited; most people order pastries or a sandwich to go
- A block off Main Street, it is quieter than the corner cafes at breakfast
Choco-Latte
dessert★ 4.4(260)
A Main Street chocolate shop and cafe making small-batch chocolates with organic, locally sourced ingredients, plus coffee drinks. Selections rotate seasonally and weekly. Good for an after-dinner sweet or a gift to take home.
3 local tips
- Offerings change weekly, so ask what is fresh that day
- A handy stop on an evening Main Street stroll
- Good for a portable treat to eat along the Shore Path