Michael and Tara Gallina's vegetable-forward fine-dining room in the Cortex district, ranked #2 best new restaurant in America by USA Today readers. Tasting menu is the kitchen's serious play.
3 local tips
- Tasting menu requires reservations weeks ahead; the bar takes walk-ins and serves the a-la-carte version.
- Wine pairings are unusually thoughtful — the optional non-alcoholic pairing is real, not consolation.
- Lunch is the easier reservation; the menu is shorter, the kitchen is the same.
Sidney Street Cafe
american
A Benton Park modern-American room that has been the city's date-night flagship for two decades. Beard semifinalist with smoked scallops and lobster turnovers as the signature dishes.
3 local tips
- Tasting menu is the right way to experience the kitchen; the a-la-carte is good but less curated.
- Reservations release four weeks out; Saturday closes fastest.
- Bar walk-ins are the back-door option on weeknights.
A Maplewood new-American spot named one of the NYT's 50 best places in America in 2025. Small dining room, scratch menu, real cocktail program.
3 local tips
- Reservations release a month out; weeknights are easier than Saturdays.
- Bar seats walk-in and serve the full menu; the wine list runs deeper than the printed page.
- Lunch is not served — this is a dinner-only kitchen.
Gerard Craft's Clayton Italian flagship — wood-fired pizza, daily pasta, gelato made in-house. Bigger and louder than the Niche-era operation it grew out of, and the kitchen has not slipped.
3 local tips
- Pasta of the day on the chalkboard is the chef's tell — order it even if you came for the pizza.
- Patio in summer is the prize seat; the indoor dining room is louder than the patio.
- Order the gelato before dessert — production runs out by 9pm some nights.
A Webster Groves new-American room with a menu that rotates seasonally and a brunch program that pulls weekend lines. Locals' default special-occasion spot west of the city.
3 local tips
- Brunch is the easier reservation; dinner books out two weeks ahead for weekends.
- Bar seats walk-in; the cocktail program is real, the wine list runs deep.
- Sister restaurant Clementine's Naughty & Nice Ice Cream is two blocks east — dessert run.
Nick Bognar's Botanical Heights Japanese-Indonesian counter — his James Beard-winning kitchen. Bite-sized format, ambitious flavors, and one of the city's only proper omakase rooms.
3 local tips
- Omakase counter is the experience; the bar serves a more casual version of the same kitchen.
- Reservations open a month out — the omakase seats close within minutes.
- Lunch is not served — this is a dinner-only counter.
Mama's on the Hill
italian
The Hill restaurant that claims toasted-ravioli origin (so does Charlie Gitto's). Family-run since the 1970s, served in a no-frills wood-paneled room. The toasted ravioli is the only correct opener.
3 local tips
- Order the toasted ravioli first, and a pasta after; the kitchen knows what it does.
- Bring cash; the staff prefers it and tabs run faster.
- Friday and Saturday lines are real; arrive at opening or expect a 30-minute wait.
Charlie Gitto's on the Hill
italian
The other toasted-ravioli origin claim, an upscale dining room since 1981 with red booths and white tablecloths. The classics done correctly without irony.
3 local tips
- Reservations strongly recommended; the formal dining room takes them seriously.
- Lobster ravioli and the veal Marsala are the two long-haul anchors.
- Bar is open without a reservation; the room is small and the menu is the same.
Anthonino's Taverna
italian
A Hill family-run Italian-Greek hybrid doing the city's reader-poll-winning toasted ravioli plus Greek classics. Sandwich-and-pasta lunch counter, formal dinner room.
3 local tips
- Order the toasted ravioli the way Anthonino's makes them — they break the format with crab and lobster versions.
- Lunch is faster and cheaper than dinner; the menu overlaps.
- BYOB is allowed with a corkage fee on Tuesdays.
Established 1957, the oldest Italian-American restaurant on the Hill. Famous for the 32-oz Frozen Fishbowl cocktails, cheese-garlic bread, and pasta in iceberg-lettuce salad bowls.
3 local tips
- Frozen Fishbowl is the local-classic order; the cheese-garlic bread comes free with most entrees.
- Cash and card both work; tabs run faster in cash.
- Lunch is open and quiet; dinner Friday/Saturday gets boisterous.
Grace Chicken + Fish
american
A Crestwood chicken-and-catfish counter from Rick Lewis of Grace Meat + Three, in the old King Edward's space on Watson Road. Casual, fast, and the city's most-defendable fried-chicken sandwich.
3 local tips
- Fried-chicken sandwich is the order; the catfish basket is the secondary play.
- Patio fills first; the indoor counter is fast.
- Sides rotate — the mac-and-cheese is the consistent winner.
Mestiza Tacos & Cantaritos
mexican
A counter-service taqueria offshoot of Malinche, with handmade tortillas and a cantarito-cocktail bar. Quick visit, sharper flavors than the format suggests.
3 local tips
- Cantarito cocktail (tequila, grapefruit, lime, salt) is the bar's calling card.
- Tortillas are made in-house; ask for handmade rather than the default.
- Patio is small but the takeout window moves fast.
Meskerem Ethiopian
vegetarian
A South Grand Ethiopian institution doing classic stews and outstanding vegetarian platters served on injera. The South Grand cultural-corridor anchor.
3 local tips
- Order the vegetarian combo platter for two — it covers most of the menu's hits.
- Coffee ceremony at the end of the meal is the kitchen's tradition; ask for it on a slow night.
- Cash is appreciated; the dining room is small and tabs run loose.
Bogart's Smokehouse
american
A Soulard barbecue counter doing apricot-glazed ribs and brisket on a Texas smoker. Locals split between this and Pappy's down the street; the apricot glaze is what sets Bogart's apart.
3 local tips
- Apricot-glazed ribs are the order; the brisket sandwich is the second-best.
- Combine with a Soulard Market walk on a Saturday morning — both are walkable.
- Meat sells out daily — Saturdays close shop by 3pm some weekends.
Pappy's Smokehouse
american
A Midtown counter-service BBQ with apple- and cherry-wood smoke. The most-recommended single restaurant for first-time visitors; lines start at 11am most days.
3 local tips
- Arrive at 11am opening or expect a 60-minute wait at noon — the line is real.
- Order the dry-rub ribs and the burnt ends; sauce is on the table for those who need it.
- Meat sells out daily — early afternoon arrivals often miss out on full lineup.
A barbecue-and-whiskey-bar group born in the Loop, doing burnt-end deviled eggs and a serious whiskey shelf. Several locations; the Hampton Avenue and Delmar shops are the originals.
3 local tips
- Burnt-end deviled eggs are the appetizer that defines the kitchen.
- Whiskey flight comparison is the bar's calling card.
- Bar seats walk-in even on Saturdays; the dining room takes reservations.
A Clayton brunch room with Mike Randolph's chef pedigree behind it. Egg-and-biscuit kitchen, espresso-bar program, and weekend lines that justify themselves.
3 local tips
- Saturday line is real; arrive at 8am opening or after 11:30am.
- Order the kale-bowl-and-biscuit combo; the egg dishes are good but the bowl is the chef's tell.
- Espresso program is real — order the drink, not the syrupy lattes.
A downtown brunch staple with multiple locations doing crepes, scratch sandwiches, and a Bloody Mary program. The downtown Locust Street original is the most-photographed.
3 local tips
- Crepes are the kitchen's anchor; the savory ham-and-Gruyere crepe is the order.
- Build-your-own Bloody Mary bar is real, not gimmick; arrive sober.
- Patio at the Locust Street location is the prize seat.
Crown Candy Kitchen
dessert
A 1913 Old North St. Louis soda fountain and candy store, still family-run and unchanged in the right ways. Phosphates, sundaes, the BLT, and the heart-attack-on-a-plate they call the Heart Stopping BLT.
3 local tips
- Get the chocolate banana malt — the malts here are the city's reference point.
- Cash speeds the line; the BLT and the malts are the right combo.
- Park on the street and walk a block; the lot fills with lunchtime regulars.
Ted Drewes Frozen Custard
dessert
The Chippewa Street and Grand Avenue frozen-custard institution that has defined St. Louis dessert since 1929. The Concrete — too thick for the spoon to fall out — is the only correct order.
3 local tips
- Order a Concrete with one mix-in; the kitchen invented the format and knows it.
- Chippewa is on Route 66 and is the original location; Grand is bigger but feels less authentic.
- Open until late; cars line up on Chippewa most warm-weather evenings.
A Ladue sourdough bakery and cafe with serious bread and a tight breakfast menu. The bread is what supplies a chunk of the city's better restaurants.
3 local tips
- Country loaf is the calling card — arrive in the morning for the first batch.
- Breakfast sandwich on company-baked focaccia is the move.
- Saturday morning sells out by noon; weekday mornings are the smart visit.
A Tower Grove single-origin coffee bar with a serious pour-over program. Smaller and more focused than the chain alternatives; coffee education is part of the order.
3 local tips
- Pour-over rather than espresso; the bar is built around single-origins.
- The bar staff will explain what they are pouring — listen rather than scrolling.
- Tower Grove location has the more focused setup; the second cafe runs more standard fare.
A Lafayette Square cafe with the city's most-defendable gooey butter cake. Counter-service coffee, sit-down booths, and the cake comes in over 70 flavors.
3 local tips
- Gooey butter cake is the local-classic; order original or chocolate first, then experiment.
- Lafayette Square is the original location; the others are extensions.
- Coffee is good but the cake is the headline.
Brasserie by Niche
mediterranean
Gerard Craft's Central West End French brasserie — steak frites, escargot, oysters, and a wine list that runs deep into Burgundy. The grown-up CWE dinner.
3 local tips
- Bar seats are first-come and serve the full menu; the dining room books out a week ahead.
- Patio is the prize summer seat — east-facing, gets the right morning light at brunch.
- Sunday brunch carries plates not on the dinner menu.