A modern coastal Italian room in the west side with a menu that changes weekly around whatever seafood and seasonal produce the kitchen feels like working with. Oysters, hand-cut pasta, and a raw bar distinguish it from anything else in town. Dress up slightly; the room is lively but feels like a destination.
3 local tips
- Reservations fill a week out on weekends — book on OpenTable the moment your travel dates are confirmed.
- Ask for the pasta special before ordering; it doesn't always make the printed menu.
- The room runs loud; if you need a quiet conversation, request a table in the back corner when booking.
Maldaner's Restaurant
american★ 4.4(321)
Springfield's oldest restaurant, open since 1884, reimagined as contemporary American fine dining with regional farmers and Mediterranean technique. The beef Wellington is the signature but the seasonal mushroom ragu is the dish locals keep coming back for. Best for a long dinner with no particular rush.
3 local tips
- The weekday business lunch prix-fixe is the best-value way to experience the kitchen.
- Downtown parking lot across from the Old State Capitol is two blocks away — use it.
- The wine list runs deep in Italian and Burgundy; ask the server to point you toward bottles with the best value, which are rarely the ones with familiar names.
D'Arcy's Pint
american★ 4.6(746)
The place Springfield locals send visitors who ask about the horseshoe sandwich — an Irish-inflected pub with a daily-changing horseshoe menu running from the classics (hamburger, turkey) to rotating specials that swap in whatever the kitchen feels like that week. Voted the city's best horseshoe repeatedly and the lines at opening prove it.
3 local tips
- Doors open at 11am and the place fills within 15 minutes — arrive at 10:50 or expect a wait.
- The 'pony shoe' is a half-size horseshoe if you want to try the dish without committing to the full portion.
- The rotating special horseshoe is the reason regulars keep coming back — ask what's on the board before defaulting to the printed menu.
Obed & Isaac's Microbrewery & Eatery
american★ 4.5(1,082)
A brewpub in a beautifully preserved Italianate mansion steps from Lincoln's home — the house-brewed beer is the real draw, but the horseshoe is considered by many regulars to be as good as D'Arcy's. The outdoor bocce court and patio are the best warm-weather drinking spots near downtown.
3 local tips
- The bocce court on the patio is first-come; show up before 5pm on weekend afternoons if you want a game.
- The mansion's original woodwork and plaster ceiling are intact — take five minutes to look up at the bar before settling in.
- Parking is tight on 6th Street; use the Capitol Complex lot on 7th and walk over.
Engrained Brewing Company
american★ 4.4(619)
Springfield's farm-to-table brewpub in the south end — the kitchen sources directly from local farms, the beer list is among the city's best, and the food goes well beyond standard pub fare. Black bean burgers, smoked salmon flatbreads, and cheese curds from a brewery that actually knows how to cook.
3 local tips
- The rotating beer list changes frequently; the taproom staff know every keg on tap and will help you navigate.
- Kid-friendly and family-oriented atmosphere — one of the few local breweries where bringing children doesn't feel awkward.
- The patio is underrated for an evening pint when the weather cooperates.
Luminary Kitchen & Provisions
american★ 4.8(125)
The restaurant Springfield locals cite when proving the city has ambitious food — small-plate-driven, seasonally obsessed, with a rotating menu that signals a kitchen genuinely cooking. Not cheap, but the cocktail program is equally strong and the room is quieter than Vele.
3 local tips
- The small plates are meant to share; plan for three or four per person to have a full meal.
- The house-made provisions (pickles, ferments, jams) are for sale at the counter — a good gift to take home.
- Reservations recommended for weekend dinners; the room is small.
Charlie Parker's Diner
american★ 4.4(455)
A classic diner in a former airplane hangar — the 16-inch pancake is the star act, but the horseshoe at lunch and the breaded walleye are equally worth the trip. Lines form before the 7am opening on weekends and the energy of the room is half the reason to go.
3 local tips
- The 16-inch pancake is a solo challenge — two people can share it as a side alongside eggs and still walk out full.
- Call ahead on Saturday mornings; the wait can be lengthy without a reservation.
- The horseshoe here uses a house-made beer cheese that's different from every other version in town — try it if you're doing a horseshoe tour.
Cozy Dog Drive In
american★ 4.2(284)
The original corn dog on a stick — Ed Waldmire developed the batter recipe here in the 1940s and the family still runs the counter on Route 66 using the same formula. The walls are covered in Route 66 memorabilia and the experience is as much about the roadside history as the food. Get one corn dog and one chili dog to compare.
3 local tips
- Cash is preferred; bring some even if you usually don't bother.
- The Route 66 gifts and merchandise in the back are genuinely good, not tourist-trap quality — a worthwhile road-trip souvenir stop.
- Open Monday through Saturday — check current hours before visiting, as they can vary by season.
Gabatoni's Italian Restaurant
italian★ 4.3(220)
A family-run Italian-American institution in Springfield's south side, using a thin-crust pizza recipe that has stayed unchanged through multiple decades of ownership. The house-made sauce and crisp crust are what regulars keep coming back for, and the toasted ravioli is a nod to the Springfield–St. Louis tradition the restaurant helped preserve.
3 local tips
- Pizza is the move — the pasta is fine but the thin-crust pies are the reason people return.
- Order ahead for pickup if you want to avoid a wait on Friday and Saturday evenings.
- The toasted ravioli is a Springfield and St. Louis tradition worth ordering as a starter.
Bella Milano Springfield
italian★ 4.3(190)
A full-service Italian restaurant in the west side that punches above its strip-mall location — brick-oven pizzas, handmade pastas, and a dining room designed to feel like a Tuscan room. Voted best Italian food and best business lunch in the Illinois Times readers poll. Good for a group that can't agree on cuisine.
3 local tips
- The private dining room in the back accommodates groups up to 60 without a buyout — call ahead.
- The brick-oven pizza is the kitchen's strength; the pastas are solid but the pizza is worth prioritizing.
- Weekday lunch specials run through mid-afternoon — better value than weekend dinner pricing.
Xochimilco Mexican Food
mexican★ 4.4(281)
A family operation on the west side serving traditional Mexican dishes done right — the enchiladas and pozole are the reliable go-tos, and the daily specials are worth asking about before ordering from the printed menu. No-frills room, consistently good food, and a loyal following of Springfield regulars.
3 local tips
- Two locations in town — the original W. Iles Ave location has the full menu and is the one to go to.
- The daily special board is almost always the best thing on offer; ask before ordering from the printed menu.
- Gets busy at Friday lunch; arrive before noon or after 1:30pm.
Roots Latin Grill
latin★ 4.7(112)
A Peruvian-inflected Latin American kitchen in the west side that opened and quickly became one of the most buzzed-about dining rooms in the city — small and big plates of tostones, camarones al ajillo, and South American-spiced dishes in a warm, energetic space. Among the highest-rated restaurants in Springfield and the most distinct from anything else in town.
3 local tips
- The cocktail program is as serious as the food — the house mezcal drinks are genuinely good.
- Make a reservation; the room is small and it fills on weekend evenings.
- The tostones empanadas are the best appetizer on the menu and sell out early — order at the start.
Custom Cup Coffee
cafe★ 4.7(55)
A downtown specialty roaster that sources and roasts its own beans on-site, ensuring every cup starts with coffee that was roasted days — not months — ago. The baked goods come from Three Twigs Bakery. One of the few spots in Springfield where serious coffee people will feel at home.
3 local tips
- Closes at 2pm on weekdays and 12:30pm Saturday — don't show up for an afternoon coffee without checking.
- The pour-over is the move if you want to taste the roast clearly; the espresso drinks are strong and reliable.
- Seating is limited; arrive early on weekday mornings before the downtown crowd fills it.
Incredibly Delicious
dessert★ 4.6(179)
A French-style bakery in a historic south-side mansion where breakfast, lunch, and serious custom cakes coexist without any of them feeling like an afterthought. Voted best bakery in Springfield by both Illinois Times and the Community's Choice Awards. The leafy outdoor garden is one of the city's nicest spots for a slow morning.
3 local tips
- Open for breakfast and lunch only — closes by 2pm weekdays, 2pm Saturday, closed Sunday and Monday.
- The outdoor garden tables fill first; arrive early if the weather is good.
- Walk-in pastries can sell out by mid-morning on Saturday — call ahead to reserve specific items.
Yellow Bird Coffee House
cafe★ 4.8(19)
A women-owned coffee house in the north end of Springfield — small-batch roasted coffee, house-made pastries and quiche, and an eclectic vibe in an older brick building. The kind of neighborhood coffee shop that doesn't feel like it's trying to be anything other than what it is.
3 local tips
- The quiche is made daily and sells out by mid-morning; it's the best food item on the menu.
- Serves the area north of downtown and near the SIU Medical Complex — closer than Custom Cup if you're staying north.
- Parking on 1st Street is easy and free, unlike most of downtown.