Glarner Stube
american★ 4.4(421)
The name translates roughly to 'New Glarus's living room,' and the long wooden bar and dozen tables live up to it — Swiss cowbells in the window, cuckoo clocks on the walls, and schnitzel on the plate. Portions are generous and come with two sides; the cheese fondue and the roesti (Swiss fried potato cakes) are the moves to make. A solid lineup of New Glarus beers pours from the taps.
4 local tips
- The cheese fondue is made for sharing — order it as a starter for the table rather than an individual appetizer.
- Roesti (crispy Swiss potato cakes) show up as a side dish and are worth requesting with nearly any entree.
- Weekend evenings book up; walk-ins at the bar are usually easier to score than a table.
- Ask the staff about the history of the building — it's been a community anchor for decades.
Canter Inn
american★ 5.0(45)
Set inside a restored 1902 Queen Anne Victorian, this is the most ambitious kitchen in town — seasonal Green County produce, local dairy, and Swiss heritage woven into contemporary small plates and tasting menus. The menu changes frequently and leans on what's growing and grazing nearby, so there's no predicting exactly what you'll find. Reservations are essential and seats fill weeks out.
4 local tips
- Reserve well ahead — this is the most reservation-dependent spot in New Glarus.
- The tasting menu showcases the kitchen's range better than ordering a la carte.
- Ask about wine pairings; the list skews toward smaller producers that complement the food.
- The Victorian dining rooms have distinct characters — request the front parlor if atmosphere matters.
Sugar River Pizza Company
american★ 4.4(217)
Right off the Sugar River State Trail trailhead, this is the natural post-ride reward: hand-tossed pies with a chewy, charred crust, housemade sauce, and toppings that don't go light. The covered patio is the place to land in good weather, especially with a cold New Glarus Spotted Cow from the tap. Gluten-free crusts are available and the kitchen is notably kid-accommodating.
4 local tips
- Lock your bike at the trailhead and walk the half block — the patio is designed for trail visitors.
- Build-your-own half-and-half pies work well if your group can't agree on toppings.
- Weekend afternoons after 1pm get busy with trail traffic; arrive early or expect a short wait.
- Cheese curds are made locally and worth adding to any order.
New Glarus Bakery
cafe★ 4.5(178)
In continuous operation since 1910, this bakery on First Street upholds Swiss and American traditions in the same small storefront: almond horns, Swiss-style rye, strudel, and brownies that regulars plan their visits around. The shop is compact and the display case turns over fast on weekends, so the earlier you arrive, the better your selection. It's the kind of place where the same families have been buying the same pastries for generations.
4 local tips
- Arrive before 9am on weekends — the almond horns and most popular items sell out by mid-morning.
- The rye bread travels well and makes an excellent souvenir alongside local cheese from a nearby shop.
- Weekday mornings are the calmest time to linger with a coffee and a pastry.
- Ask what came out of the oven that morning — fresh items are worth waiting a few minutes for.
Sportsman's Reloaded Bar & Grill
american★ 4.2(120)
The place to go when everything else in town has called it a night — the kitchen runs late and the beer list covers the widest selection of New Glarus taps you'll find under one roof. Burgers, cheese curds, reubens, and onion rings hold their own as bar food goes; the atmosphere is low-key local and genuinely welcoming to out-of-towners.
4 local tips
- This is the spot if you want New Glarus beer variety — the tap list runs deeper here than most places in town.
- The kitchen stays open later than competitors, making it the best late-evening option.
- Unbreaded cheese curds are the local-approved order — skip the breaded version.
- The bar fills with locals on weekend nights; it's one of the better spots to strike up a conversation.
Puempel's Olde Tavern
american★ 4.1(73)
Founded in 1893, this bar has the bones to prove it: the original 1912 all-wood back bar stands intact, murals painted in 1913 cover the walls, and the ceiling is papered in dollar bills (twice a year the house sweeps half of them down and donates the proceeds to local charities). The menu is deliberately short — bratwurst sandwich, Italian beef, naked cheese curds, broccoli cheddar soup in a bread bowl — and the prices are refreshingly honest.
4 local tips
- The naked (unbreaded) cheese curds are the bar snack to order here.
- Look up at the dollar-bill ceiling and ask the bartender about the charity collection tradition.
- This is the oldest continuously operating tavern in town — the history is part of the experience.
- Cash is king here; have some on hand.
Ohana Kitchen
american★ 4.3(110)
An unexpected left turn in a Swiss village: Hawaiian-influenced plates — kalua pork, poke-style bowls, pesto chicken sandwiches — served in a cheerful space with a well-used outdoor area. The contrast between the cuisine and the surroundings is part of the appeal, and the kitchen pulls it off with food that stands on its own without needing the novelty. Locals adopted it quickly.
4 local tips
- The outdoor patio is the best seat in good weather — grab it before the lunch rush.
- The pesto chicken sandwich has become a local staple; it's a reliable order.
- The vibe is casual and kid-friendly — good option if you're traveling with family.
- Check the specials board for rotating Hawaiian-inspired items not on the regular menu.