Driftless Glen Restaurant
american★ 4.5(498)
The dining room of Baraboo's craft distillery along the Baraboo River, with a menu that reaches well beyond pub food — think locally sourced steaks, creative appetizers, and serious cocktails made with the house spirits. The setting on the water is relaxed and the kitchen punches above the usual distillery-restaurant standard. One of the region's better all-around dinner spots.
4 local tips
- Sit on the river patio when weather allows — it's the best seat in town
- The house whiskeys and gin are worth sampling before dinner
- Reservations are advisable on summer weekends
- The bar menu is a solid option if you want to eat lighter
Little Village Cafe
american★ 4.6(206)
A restored 1940s diner on the courthouse square where the original booths, counter stools and neon set the scene for an eclectic menu — burgers and burritos alongside fresh seafood, pasta and homemade soups, with a full bar and plenty of vegetarian and gluten-free options. It serves lunch and dinner rather than breakfast, and fills up on weekends.
4 local tips
- The menu roams from burgers to burritos to seafood — homemade soups and daily specials round it out
- There's a full bar plus vegetarian and gluten-free options, unusual for a spot this size
- The counter seats are the best spot for watching the full diner operation in motion
- Open for lunch and dinner until 8pm (9pm Fri-Sat) and closed Sundays — plan around that
Broadway Diner
american★ 4.5(180)
A fully restored 1954 Silk City diner car on downtown Broadway, operating as an all-day spot for eggs, burgers and blue-plate comfort food. The stainless-steel bones and vinyl booths feel authentic, and the food is straightforward and satisfying. A reliable stop before or after Devil's Lake.
4 local tips
- Try the homemade soups — they rotate and are consistently good
- Seating is limited; small groups fare better than large ones
- Breakfast runs all day, which makes scheduling easy
- Parking is easier a block off Broadway toward the river
Log Cabin Family Restaurant
american★ 4.4(361)
A family-run restaurant and bakery that built its reputation on fresh-baked pies and generous home-style plates, open from breakfast through dinner. The cozy room fills quickly with regulars and visitors alike, and the pie case near the register makes leaving harder than expected. Owned and operated with real pride.
4 local tips
- The pies change by season — ask what's fresh that day before you order
- The fish fry and daily dinner specials have a following — the kitchen runs through the evening
- Can get crowded on weekend mornings; earlier is better
- Takeout pies are available and travel well for a Devil's Lake picnic
Mike's Italian Restaurant
italian★ 4.8(268)
A West Baraboo neighborhood Italian spot that flies well under the tourist radar and earns serious loyalty from locals for its pasta, pizza and traditional red-sauce dishes. The room is no-frills, the portions are honest and the quality consistently delivers. Worth seeking out for a low-key dinner.
4 local tips
- Bring cash or check payment options ahead — it's a neighborhood joint
- The pizza and pasta are the reliable choices; stick to the classics
- Quieter on weeknights than weekend evenings
- It's a short drive from downtown — easily combined with a Devil's Lake day
Tumbled Rock Kitchen & Brewery
american★ 4.1(115)
A brewpub just outside Devil's Lake State Park with sunken fire pits, a big outdoor lawn and a tap list of house-brewed beers worth working through. The food is pubby and approachable, and the setting makes it a natural post-hike stop. The outdoor space is the real draw when the weather cooperates.
4 local tips
- The fire pits on the patio fill up fast on fall evenings — arrive early
- Order a flight to narrow down the tap list before committing
- The kitchen and bar are in separate buildings; order food when you arrive
- Just outside the park's north entrance — ideal for a stop after a bluff hike
Al. Ringling Brewing Co.
american★ 4.3(130)
Baraboo's downtown brewpub occupies a space layered with circus history, pouring house-brewed beers alongside empanadas and pub food with South American influence — the owner's heritage shows up in the kitchen in a good way. The shrimp empanada and the cream ale have developed real followings. A friendly neighborhood spot.
4 local tips
- The empanadas are worth ordering regardless of what else you get
- The circus artifacts on display throughout the space reward some unhurried looking
- Flight orders let you sample the range efficiently
- On the smaller side; weekend evenings can get lively
Gem City Saloon & Eatery
american★ 4.6(136)
A casual downtown bar and grill on the square with a wide selection of draft beers, solid pizza and a menu that covers the bar-food bases without cutting corners. The room is lively without being loud, and the staff makes strangers feel welcome. A dependable spot for an easy evening.
4 local tips
- The pizza has developed a real local following — order it over the standard bar apps
- Good craft beer selection on draft; ask what's local
- Central square location makes it easy to walk to from anywhere downtown
- Weekend evenings get busy — arrive by 7 to get a table without a wait
Las Milpas Restaurant & Store
mexican★ 4.5(85)
A small Mexican restaurant-and-grocery hybrid on 8th Avenue where the kitchen turns out homemade tamales, tacos and burritos from scratch using quality ingredients. The atmosphere is casual and communal, and the authenticity is genuine. A standout for Mexican food in a part of Wisconsin where the options can be thin.
4 local tips
- The tamales are a must when available — ask if they're fresh that day
- The grocery side stocks hard-to-find Mexican and Latin American ingredients
- Go for lunch; it can close earlier than listed hours
- Cash is strongly preferred