Michael's Seafood Restaurant
seafood★ 4.5(1,200)
The undisputed anchor of the Carolina Beach dining scene, open year-round when most island spots go dark. The award-winning seafood chowder — thick, creamy, layered with clams and fish — is the real reason to come, and locals order it regardless of the season. The menu runs deep into fresh local catch, and the crab cake sandwich is a reliable benchmark for the island.
4 local tips
- The chowder is available by the quart to go — grab one if you're self-catering.
- Make reservations for summer weekends; walk-ins can face a long wait.
- Open year-round, so this is your go-to during shoulder season when others close.
- Ask about daily fresh catch specials, which rotate based on what came in that morning.
Havana's Restaurant
seafood★ 4.4(816)
Set inside a genuine 1916 beach cottage at the south end of the main drag, Havana's does a polished casual thing that most Pleasure Island spots don't attempt. The crab dip with house-made chips is the move to start, and the Honey Bourbon salmon and shrimp and grits have a following among regulars. Sunday brunch here is the best on the island — the kitchen actually earns that distinction.
4 local tips
- Sunday brunch fills up fast — arrive early or expect a wait.
- The crab dip with house chips is worth ordering even if it's not on your usual radar.
- Patio seating in the cottage garden is the best spot when weather cooperates.
- The bourbon and wine selection is notably deeper than the typical beach bar.
Shuckin' Shack Oyster Bar
seafood★ 4.3(540)
The best place on the island to pull up and eat a pile of oysters without any ceremony. Started by two locals who wanted a shellfish bar without the pretense, and that ethos stuck — nautical-rustic interior, buckets on the table, and an affordable menu built around responsibly sourced bivalves. The Lowcountry boil and lobster rolls are solid too, and it holds up well year-round.
4 local tips
- Oysters come in several preparations — raw, steamed, chargrilled — worth trying the chargrilled if you're new to oysters.
- The Lowcountry boil feeds two people comfortably and is a good deal.
- They have an outdoor deck that catches the afternoon breeze.
- Sustainability-focused — they run a 'Skip the Straw' program and source shellfish responsibly.
The only dock-and-dine on the island: park your boat at the back slip and walk straight in. The canal-side setting on a converted dock creates a genuinely relaxed atmosphere that shore-side places can't replicate. Blackened mahi, lump crab dip, and the Captain's Fish Sandwich are the reliable choices, and live music on weekend evenings makes it the right place to linger.
4 local tips
- Arrive by boat if you can — the back dock accepts boats for dine-in guests.
- Live music runs Friday and Saturday evenings; worth timing your visit around it.
- The lump crab dip with crusty bread is the right way to start.
- Weekday lunches are much more relaxed than peak weekend evenings.
Salt Fish Restaurant and Tiki Bar
seafood★ 4.5(290)
A small, creative kitchen that leans into Caribbean and Polynesian flavors in a way that actually works — the half-pineapple loaded with shrimp and the tuna poke are the signatures that regulars reorder. The tiki cocktails are serious, not sweet-syrup afterthoughts, and the compact space means the kitchen stays focused. Reservations are needed; walk-ins rarely get seated in season.
4 local tips
- Reservations are genuinely necessary in summer — the space is small and fills quickly.
- The half-pineapple shrimp dish and tuna poke are the creative standouts; don't skip them.
- Tiki cocktails here have real craft behind them — worth trying something from the cocktail list.
- Parking is limited; walk or bike from nearby rentals if you can.
SeaWitch Cafe & Tiki Bar
seafood★ 4.3(480)
The liveliest patio on the island most summer evenings, with live music, waterfront sunset views, and a menu that punches above the tiki-bar genre. The ahi tuna nachos and crab dip are the food hits, while the Mahi tacos work at lunch. It operates year-round with more regularity than most Carolina Beach spots, and the weekday happy hour specials are worth knowing about.
4 local tips
- Happy hour weekday specials on drinks are a genuine deal — check what's running that week.
- Arrive before sunset for the best patio seats with water views.
- The ahi tuna nachos are the kitchen's most distinctive dish; order them.
- Live music schedule varies — check their social media for who's playing which night.
Soul Flavor
american★ 4.6(233)
A relaxed bar-restaurant that doesn't fit neatly into the island's seafood-or-burgers binary. The Sea Pho — a coastal spin on Vietnamese pho using local seafood — is the standout you won't find anywhere else on Pleasure Island. The space plays jazz and decorates with images of soul musicians, giving it a personality that stands out among the beach shacks. Evening-only, Tuesday through Saturday.
4 local tips
- The Sea Pho is the dish to order — it's genuinely different from anything else on the island.
- Open evenings only from Tuesday to Saturday; plan lunch elsewhere.
- The bar program is stronger than you'd expect for a beach town restaurant.
- Smaller capacity means it fills up — arrive at opening or call ahead.
Gulfstream Restaurant
brunch★ 4.4(380)
Family-owned since 1978 and proudly unchanged — breakfast and lunch only, closing at 2pm, and focused on doing classic American morning food well. The corned beef hash, biscuits, and classic seafood lunch plates have built a multigenerational regulars base that packs the place on weekend mornings. Come early or expect a wait; there's no reservations system here.
4 local tips
- Arrive before 9am on weekends to avoid the line — it fills up fast.
- Closes at 2pm daily; this is strictly a breakfast and lunch destination.
- The corned beef hash and biscuits are the local's breakfast order.
- Cash is appreciated though cards are accepted; the vibe is old-school diner.
Kate's Pancake House
brunch★ 4.3(420)
The island's dedicated pancake institution, with a menu of variations broad enough to make the decision genuinely difficult. Sweet potato pancakes, s'mores pancakes, and pigs-n-blanket are the house signatures, but the eggs benedict and biscuits hold their own. Fills up quickly on weekends and the line moves on its own schedule — budget time and it's worth it.
4 local tips
- The sweet potato pancakes and s'mores pancakes are the crowd-pleasers worth ordering.
- Weekend waits can be 30-45 minutes — bring patience or go on a weekday.
- The biscuits are made fresh and worth ordering as a side.
- Smaller table sizes mean groups of 6+ may face longer waits to seat together.
Nollie's Taco Joint
mexican★ 4.3(260)
A So-Cal-inspired taco spot that landed on the island and found its crowd quickly. The vibe is intentionally grungy — skateboard decor, bright walls, unhurried pace — and the tacos, burritos, and nachos are lighter and more California than anything Tex-Mex. Solid vegan and vegetarian options make it a useful fallback when the group has mixed dietary preferences. All-day breakfast tacos are a bonus.
4 local tips
- All-day breakfast tacos are available anytime — a good option if you missed the morning rush.
- Vegan and vegetarian options are genuinely good, not an afterthought.
- The patio with beer selection is the right way to eat here on a warm afternoon.
- Service can be slow on busy days — set expectations accordingly and enjoy the pace.
Hang Ten Grill
american★ 4.3(310)
The surf-inspired kitchen that uses Southern ingredients as the backbone — think fried green tomatoes, pimento cheese, and local shrimp folded into a menu that bridges burgers, sandwiches, and coastal plates. The shrimp burger is the signature, and the fried okra side is better than it has any right to be. Beach attire is welcome, the space fits groups, and weekend brunch is a solid option.
4 local tips
- The shrimp burger is the standout order — it's what makes this different from a standard grill.
- Fried okra is worth adding as a side; it converts okra skeptics.
- Beach attire is explicitly welcome — no need to change after a morning on the sand.
- Weekend breakfast runs seasonally; check current hours before planning a morning visit.
Britt's Donut Shop
dessert★ 4.7(890)
One item only since 1939: glazed donuts. No sprinkles, no cream filling, no other options — just the original recipe, cooked to order in the same boardwalk spot for generations. The line is part of the experience on summer mornings, and the donuts are grease-translucent in the best possible way. Cash only, seasonal, and worth every minute of the wait.
4 local tips
- Cash only — bring bills, there's no card reader.
- Open seasonally (roughly April through October); closed the rest of the year.
- The line moves steadily even when it looks long — donuts come out fast.
- Morning visits right at opening get the freshest batches and shortest waits.
Jack Mackerel's Island Grill
seafood★ 4.2(290)
The go-to spot in Kure Beach proper — a casual island grill with a menu built around burgers, wraps, fresh seafood, and steaks that serves the southern end of Pleasure Island well. The grilled fish and crab cakes lean into local sourcing, and the cocktail program keeps the patio energized on warm evenings. The service can be stretched on peak summer nights, but the food is consistent.
4 local tips
- The crab cakes and grilled fish are the kitchen's strengths — lean toward seafood here.
- Patio seating is the preferred spot in the evening; request it when you arrive.
- Service slows considerably on busy summer Friday and Saturday evenings — plan extra time.
- Closer to Fort Fisher and the aquarium, making it a natural stop after a southern-island day.