A converted historic boathouse at the end of Front Street — the longtime Front Street Grill at Stillwater, now rebranded The Rhumbar — serving coastal fare with a Caribbean lean and rum cocktails like the signature Painkiller. The dining room and waterfront bar look straight across Taylor's Creek to Carrot Island, so you can watch wild ponies graze while you eat. Every seat feels like a window seat.
3 local tips
- Ask for the dock-side tables early — they fill before the dining room does
- The Painkiller is stronger than it tastes; pace yourself if you're still exploring the town after lunch
- Sunsets over the creek from here are worth timing your dinner reservation around
Aqua Restaurant
mediterranean★ 4.6(581)
Beaufort's original tapas spot, tucked in an alley off Front Street, where the whole point is ordering too much and sharing everything. The menu swings between local seafood and global flavors — ceviche sits next to lamb chops — and the wine list runs 80-plus bottles. The room is small and candlelit; locals pack it on weekends.
3 local tips
- Order at least 4-5 small plates per couple — they're generously sized but meant for sharing
- Make a reservation; walk-ins on weekends often wait over an hour
- The charcuterie and local catch ceviche are reliable anchors to build the rest of the table around
Beaufort Grocery Co.
american
A bistro in a white clapboard building on Queen Street that does double duty — relaxed deli sandwiches and homemade soups at lunch shift to a proper dinner menu of fresh fish, lamb, and seasonal specials come evening. The garden patio out back is a neighborhood secret. The desserts are made in-house and not an afterthought.
3 local tips
- The lunch menu is much more casual and affordable than dinner — great for a mid-day break between exploring
- Grab a patio table in the garden on warm nights; it fills up but turns over steadily
- Homemade cornbread arrives with dinner; don't wave it off
A wood-fired pizza spot on the Front Street boardwalk with Rachel Carson Reserve views straight from the outdoor deck. The pies lean Neapolitan with a local twist — blue crab dip arrives as an app and there's a rotating cast of seasonal toppings. Best for a casual lunch or afternoon after a morning on the water.
3 local tips
- The outdoor boardwalk seats face Carrot Island — get there at low tide when the ponies come down to the water
- The crab dip with house-made flatbread is the table opener worth ordering before pizzas arrive
- Wednesday through Sunday only; closed Monday and Tuesday
Clawson's 1905 Restaurant
seafood
Operating in the same building as a 1905 waterfront grocery store, this downtown staple does seafood and pub food without any pretension. The fish sandwiches and local catch are the move; the upstairs bar area gets lively. A solid choice when you want something reliably good in the middle of a busy day of wandering.
3 local tips
- The upstairs bar gets louder and more social as the evening goes on — downstairs is quieter
- The lunch specials are the best value on the menu; check the board when you walk in
- Walk-in friendly unlike some neighbours, but weekends can still get backed up
A three-story restaurant on Front Street with a rooftop Sky Deck that gives you 360-degree views over Taylor's Creek and the harbor. The kitchen runs Caribbean-coastal flavors — think seafood with island sauces and fresh-caught local fish — with a wine list that's won Wine Spectator recognition several years running. Best at sunset.
3 local tips
- Reserve the rooftop Sky Deck specifically; the main floor is fine but the view up top is the reason to come
- The early-evening happy hour on the Sky Deck fills fast on summer weekends
- Parking is easier if you walk from the town parking lot rather than circling Front Street
The kind of neighborhood deli that anchors a downtown — good sandwiches, salads, local wine, and craft beer in a friendly room on Turner Street. Breakfast and lunch are the play here; it's a one-stop grab-and-go or sit-down spot that locals use as a daily rhythm. Friday family meals are a weekly institution for regulars.
3 local tips
- The Friday meal pickup is a genuine local ritual — if you're here midweek, ask what Friday's offering is
- Great spot to grab provisions if you're heading out on a boat day
- One of the few places open early enough to fuel up before the ferry to Shackleford
A tiny French bakery on Broad Street operating three days a week — baguettes Thursday and Friday, croissants and viennoiseries Saturday only. The owner learned to bake in France and it shows: the crust on the baguettes crackles and the croissants are laminated properly. Beaufort has been quietly obsessed since it opened.
3 local tips
- Get there right at the 9am Saturday open if you want croissants — they sell out fast
- Thursday and Friday baguettes are the move if you're making a picnic for a beach or ferry day
- Cash is appreciated; the queue moves fast so have your order ready
Cru Wine Bar & Coffee
cafe
Turner Street's all-day anchor — specialty coffee and pastries from early morning shift into wine and sandwiches by afternoon. It fills the gap between breakfast spots and dinner reservation territory with a relaxed room that locals use for laptop work, long lunches, and pre-dinner bottles. One of the more comfortable spots in town to linger.
3 local tips
- Opens at 6:30am — one of the earliest spots in town for coffee before a morning ferry or paddle
- The wine list skews small-producer and interesting; ask the staff what they've been opening lately
- Midweek afternoons are the quietest time to grab a corner and settle in for a couple of hours
34° North Restaurant
seafood
Out at the Beaufort Hotel on Lennoxville Road with a dock-to-table menu that draws heavily from what the local fleet brings in that morning. The dining room overlooks Taylor's Creek and the views at dusk across to the marsh are genuinely good. More of a destination dinner than a casual stop — worth the short drive from downtown.
3 local tips
- Request a table facing the water when booking; the creek views are the setting that makes the meal
- The catch of the day is always the freshest thing on the menu — ask what the local boats landed that morning
- Hotel guests get priority for prime tables on busy weekends, so book well ahead