Local Guide

Block Island, RI

Hand-curated local recommendations around Block Island, RI — 10 restaurants, 6 trails and outdoor spots, 5 things to do and 6 landmarks, each with a written note and practical tips for visitors and short-term-rental guests.

27 Local Picks in Block Island

Researched and written by hand, not scraped. Every entry below is a real place near Block Island, with a note on what it actually is and the practical tips a local would give you.

Restaurants & cafés (10)Trails & outdoors (6)Things to do (5)Landmarks & sights (6)

Restaurants & cafés in Block Island

Eli's

american

A beloved, intimate bistro on Chapel Street in Old Harbor that has been turning out creative seasonal fare since 1994. Pan-seared halibut, the Eli's burger, and vegetable sofrito are perennial favorites. It fills fast and earns its reputation as the most reliably good dinner on the island.

3 local tips
  • Reserve ahead — the room is small and it books up on summer weekends
  • The daily specials reflect whatever came off the boats that morning, order them over the menu standbys
  • If you are a walk-in, the bar seats are your best chance

Atlantic Inn Restaurant

american

The island's most refined dining room, set in a hillside Victorian inn with sweeping sunset views across the island. Small and large plates lean toward local fish, game, and vegetables; the wine list holds a Wine Spectator Award of Excellence. A step up in polish from most island options.

3 local tips
  • Reserve well ahead — the hilltop terrace tables for sunset are the most sought-after seats
  • Dress slightly nicer than flip-flops; it is not a jacket place but it is the island's fine-dining anchor
  • The wine list is extensive by island standards — ask the server for guidance by the glass

Dead Eye Dick's

seafood4.4(293)

A New Harbor institution with an open-air deck right on the Great Salt Pond, known for fresh swordfish, lobster, an extensive raw bar, and homemade soups. The view of the boat traffic makes it as good for lingering over drinks as for a full seafood dinner. One of the island's most consistently praised waterfront spots.

3 local tips
  • The raw bar is the anchor — start there while you wait for a table
  • Waterfront deck seats go first; arrive early or be prepared to wait at the bar
  • Creative cocktails and local microbrews are worth exploring alongside the seafood

The Oar

seafood4.3(346)

A casual waterside restaurant on Jobs Hill Road with a wide patio of picnic tables and Adirondack chairs facing the water. Baked Atlantic cod, lobster rolls, and shrimp-and-pea pasta are the draws; the price is right and the vibe is reliably relaxed. A family-friendly favorite for post-beach dinners.

3 local tips
  • The patio fills fast in summer — arrive by 5:30 pm or expect a wait
  • Lobster rolls are solid and priced fairly for the island; a lighter option than a full seafood spread
  • Good for families with kids; the outdoor seating and laid-back energy handle noise well

Poor People's Pub

american

A surf-shack-style Old Harbor pub founded by two unemployed contractors in 1974, still serving burgers, BBQ, pizza, and local seafood at unpretentious prices. The pulled pork mac and cheese and crispy fish sticks are house signatures. Live music on weekends makes it the island's most reliably lively evening hangout.

3 local tips
  • The pulled pork mac and cheese is the dish that regulars order without looking at the menu
  • Live music nights draw a crowd — great for soaking up the local bar scene
  • One of the better value-for-money options on an island where prices skew high in summer

Ballard's Beach Restaurant

seafood

A sprawling, festive oceanfront institution with its own sandy beach, marina, and outdoor bar — the closest Block Island gets to a beach-club atmosphere. The food centers on New England seafood standards; the experience is as much about the setting as the plate. Best for a long, sociable afternoon lunch.

3 local tips
  • Arrive by boat for the full Ballard's experience — dock slips are available
  • Expect a crowd and a lively atmosphere rather than a quiet dinner; this is a party venue at heart
  • The outdoor bar and beach area are the draw; sit inside only if the weather forces it

Ernie's Old Harbor Restaurant

brunch

The island's go-to breakfast and brunch spot, with a covered harbor-view deck that frames the ferry traffic. Classic American diner food — eggs, pancakes, and hearty morning plates — at reasonable prices. Families pile in here before hitting the beaches.

3 local tips
  • Lines form by 9 am in summer; go at 7:30 am or be prepared to wait outside
  • Grab a deck seat for front-row views of the morning ferry arrivals
  • Closes by early afternoon, so this is strictly a breakfast/brunch stop

Mahogany Shoals

american4.3(16)

A dockside bar at Payne's Dock in New Harbor with bright, hip decor and a serious cocktail game — painkillers, mudslides, and bloody marys are the stars. Food is secondary to the drinks and the vibe, but the snacks and light bites satisfy. The best sundowner perch on the water.

3 local tips
  • Cash only at the bar — come prepared
  • The painkiller is the signature order; try it once even if rum is not your usual
  • Crowds peak at golden hour; arrive 30 minutes before sunset for a waterfront seat

Aldo's Bakery & Handmade Ice Cream

dessert

A family-run Old Harbor institution on Weldon's Way since 1970, beloved for handmade ice cream and gelato, morning pastries, and fresh-baked breads. Aldo's is best known for the 'Andiamo' bakery boat that motors through the Great Salt Pond each morning, calling out to moored boats and delivering hot coffee, muffins, and warm breakfast to the deck. Fifty-plus years on, it remains the island's essential sweet stop.

3 local tips
  • Get the handmade gelato — the flavors rotate and the cones are made in-house
  • If you are anchored in the Great Salt Pond, listen for the 'Andiamo' pastry boat early in the morning
  • Open early to late in season; come for warm pastries at dawn or ice cream after dinner

The Beachhead

american

A low-key Corn Neck Road bar and restaurant overlooking Crescent Beach, with a loyal local following and a deck facing the water. Known for straightforward burgers, sandwiches, chowder, and fresh local seafood done honestly, it is where islanders eat when they are not performing for tourists. A genuine neighborhood spot with a weekday raw-bar happy hour.

3 local tips
  • The Buck-a-Shuck raw-bar special (weekday afternoons) is one of the better deals on the island
  • Good option when the Old Harbor waterfront spots have two-hour waits
  • Grab a deck seat for the Crescent Beach view; the bar area is the local social hub

Trails & outdoors in Block Island

Clay Head Trail

A 3.6-mile coastal trail along the island's northeast bluffs through a 150-acre Nature Conservancy preserve, with open Atlantic views, clay sea-cliffs, and the labyrinthine unmarked side trails locals call the Maze. The combination of ocean panorama, freshwater swamp, and rolling meadow makes it the island's single best hike.

3 local tips
  • The Maze — the unmarked web of trails through the scrub — is worth getting slightly lost in; it is disorienting in the best way
  • Look for the parking area on Corn Neck Road about two miles north of town, then walk down the dirt road
  • Morning is best for birding in the swamp; afternoon brings the best light on the bluffs

Rodman's Hollow Trail

A 3.65-mile loop through a glacial outwash plain — the first piece of land conserved on Block Island in 1972 and still the ecological heart of the island. Shad trees bloom in spring, the federally threatened American Burying Beetle lives here, and the trail opens to ocean views at the southwest end. Moderate with some steep slopes.

3 local tips
  • Spring bloom (late April to May) transforms the hollow with shad trees; worth timing a visit around it
  • The southwest end of the trail opens to Black Rock Beach — a dramatic, rarely crowded cove
  • Bring water; there is no shade on the exposed sections and the return climb is steeper than it looks

Mohegan Bluffs Trail

A clifftop walking path skirting the south-shore bluffs between the Southeast Lighthouse and the Mohegan Bluffs overlook, combining two of the island's most iconic viewpoints in a single 2-mile stretch. The trail traces the cliff edge with the Atlantic 200 feet below and offers the best wind-farm views on the island.

3 local tips
  • Do not lean on or step beyond the cliff-edge barriers — erosion makes the lip unstable
  • Walk east to west (lighthouse to bluffs overlook) to have the sun at your back in the morning
  • The 141-step staircase down to the beach is at the Mohegan Bluffs end; factor in the climb back up

Block Island Greenway — Payne Rd to Beacon Hill Rd

A 5.6-mile interior traverse crossing the island's spine through open scrubland, stone walls, and the highest point on the island, Beacon Hill. The route connects Black Rock Beach to Rodman's Hollow and samples more than 30 miles of greenway trails. The most varied single outing on the island in terms of terrain and habitat.

3 local tips
  • A car shuttle or bike at one end saves backtracking; the one-way traverse is more satisfying than the out-and-back
  • Beacon Hill Road end has slightly better parking; start there and walk south toward Payne Road
  • Mid-week in summer is dramatically quieter than weekends on this inland route

North Lighthouse Sandy Beach Walk

A 1.5-mile out-and-back along Sandy Point beach through the National Wildlife Refuge to the granite North Lighthouse, the most remote and atmospheric walk on the island. The dune scrub on one side and open ocean on the other create a genuine sense of wilderness unusual for such a small island.

3 local tips
  • Wear shoes that can get wet; the narrow spit means tides can briefly wash the path at the northern tip
  • Best in early morning when bird activity in the refuge is highest and you may have the beach to yourself
  • The parking area at the end of Corn Neck Road is the trailhead; do not try to drive beyond the gate

Enchanted Forest Trail

A short, shaded woodland loop in the center of the island through dense scrub oak and cherry — unusual on an island dominated by open heath and bluffs. The trail is unmarked and intimate, popular with birders during migration for the songbird concentration it creates. A good counterpoint to the exposed coastal routes.

3 local tips
  • Bring a trail map from the Greenway kiosk at the trailhead — the woodland paths are not well signed
  • Fall migration (September to October) fills the canopy with warblers and thrushes
  • Combine with the Rodman's Hollow Trail for a longer half-day outing across the south end of the island

Things to do in Block Island

Pond and Beyond Kayak Rentals and Tours

The island's most established kayak operation, based at New Harbor behind Smuggler's, offering rentals, guided tours, and basic instruction for paddling the Great Salt Pond. The sheltered pond is ideal for beginners; guided tours extend to birding and snorkeling excursions. The gentlest way to see the New Harbor ecosystem up close.

3 local tips
  • Book tours ahead in July and August — guided spots fill within a day or two of availability
  • The Great Salt Pond is calm and safe for first-time kayakers; no experience needed for rentals
  • Sunset tours are popular and worth the premium for the light on the water

Block Island Bike Rentals (Old Harbor)

The classic way to see the island, with multiple rental shops clustered near the Old Harbor ferry dock renting beach cruisers, mountain bikes, and mopeds by the hour or day. The flat northern loop on Corn Neck Road is perfect for families; the south-shore hills reward those on geared bikes. Most of the island's sights are reachable within a 20-minute ride.

3 local tips
  • Rent first thing after the ferry docks — bikes sell out on peak summer days by late morning
  • The flat northern loop (Corn Neck Road to Crescent Beach) is the best intro ride
  • Corn Neck Road gets busy midday; ride early morning or late afternoon for a quieter experience

Glass Float Project

A beloved annual art-meets-treasure-hunt tradition in which over 500 hand-blown glass spheres are hidden around the island each June through early October. Finders keep their float permanently. It has become a ritual for returning visitors, with clues posted online and floats hidden everywhere from trail heads to tidal pools.

3 local tips
  • Check the official Glass Float website for clues and the daily hide schedule
  • Floats are hidden island-wide, not just beaches — look on trails, near lighthouses, and in town
  • Finding a float is genuinely rare and the element of surprise is the point; avoid spoiler communities

Block Island Ferry (Seasonal Crossing)

The hour-long ferry crossing from Point Judith on the Block Island Ferry is itself part of the island experience, with open ocean views, occasional dolphin sightings, and the dramatic approach to Old Harbor with its Victorian hotels. High-speed service from Point Judith and seasonal service from Newport and New London also run.

3 local tips
  • Book car passage months in advance for summer weekends — foot passengers can usually board same-day
  • The high-speed ferry from Point Judith (30 minutes) is more expensive but worth it on choppy days
  • Bring layers even in summer — the crossing is cold and windy once you leave the harbor

Abrams Animal Farm

A small petting farm near the center of the island with exotic and domestic animals including camels, llamas, fainting goats, and emus — one of the island's few family-specific attractions. Unexpected on a remote Atlantic island and reliably fun for younger children who have been hiking all day.

3 local tips
  • Check seasonal hours before visiting — the farm operates on a limited schedule outside peak summer
  • Kids can feed most animals directly; bring small bills for the feed dispensers
  • A short, easy stop that pairs well with a Greenway trail walk on the same side of the island

Landmarks & sights in Block Island

Southeast Lighthouse

A National Historic Landmark brick lighthouse perched atop Mohegan Bluffs, guiding mariners since 1875 and relocated back from the eroding cliff edge in 1993 in a celebrated feat of engineering. The red-brick Gothic Revival tower and keeper's house are among the most photographed structures in New England. The site also offers the best mainland view of the offshore Block Island Wind Farm.

3 local tips
  • Guided tower climbs and the museum run roughly Memorial Day through Columbus Day (daily in midsummer) — worth timing your visit to catch one
  • The bluff-edge viewpoint just south of the lighthouse looks straight down to the rocky beach 200 feet below
  • Golden hour light on the red brick is exceptional; arrive 45 minutes before sunset

Mohegan Bluffs

Two-hundred-foot clay and glacial-till sea cliffs stretching along the island's south shore — among the most dramatic coastal scenery in Rhode Island. A wooden staircase of 141 steps descends to a remote, rock-strewn beach where you are likely to have long stretches to yourself. The clifftop path offers unbroken Atlantic views and excellent birding.

3 local tips
  • The 141-step descent is steep and the climb back up is tiring — wear proper footwear
  • The beach at the bottom is rocky and not for swimming; come for the scenery and solitude
  • Pair with the Southeast Lighthouse, a ten-minute walk east along Mohegan Trail

Block Island National Wildlife Refuge

A 127-acre refuge at the island's northern tip protecting migratory shorebirds and songbirds along one of the Atlantic Flyway's key corridors. Sandy Beach and the dunes around Sandy Point form the heart of it, with Settlers' Rock — a granite boulder marking the 1661 landing of the island's first English settlers — at the very tip.

3 local tips
  • Spring and fall migration periods bring extraordinary bird diversity; pack binoculars
  • Dogs must be leashed; nesting season restrictions apply in the dune areas — watch for signage
  • Combine with the North Lighthouse (a short walk from Settlers' Rock) for a full northern-tip outing

North Lighthouse

A granite lighthouse at the island's northern tip, accessible by a 20-minute walk along Sandy Beach through the wildlife refuge. The fourth lighthouse built on this treacherous point since 1829, now housing a small maritime museum. The walk through the dunes to reach it is itself one of the island's most scenic stretches.

3 local tips
  • The sandy beach walk in is the experience — allow 45 minutes round trip from the parking area
  • The museum inside is small but well done; check opening hours as it is seasonal
  • Tide affects the width of the beach; check conditions if you plan to walk at the water's edge

Crescent Beach (State Beach)

A two-mile arc of calm Atlantic sand on the island's east side, the most swimmable and family-friendly stretch on Block Island. The gentle surf and firm sand make it the default beach day destination, with a snack shack and lifeguards in season. Stretches from Old Harbor north to Settler's Rock Road.

3 local tips
  • The northern end near Scotch Beach is less crowded than the main State Beach parking area
  • Surf is calmer here than the south shore — best swimming on the island for children
  • The beach is a long walk from most accommodations; rent a bike and ride Corn Neck Road to reach it easily

Old Harbor Historic District

The island's Victorian commercial heart clustered around the ferry dock, with late-1800s wooden hotels, shingled storefronts, and the busy waterfront intact. Architecturally the most cohesive Victorian streetscape in Rhode Island, it survived the 20th century largely unchanged. Worth a slow walk even for non-architecture people.

3 local tips
  • Pick up a walking-tour map at the Block Island Historical Society on Old Town Road
  • The National Hotel porch is the island's original see-and-be-seen perch — have a drink there
  • Most shops and restaurants are within a five-minute walk of the ferry landing, making this easy to explore on arrival

Hosting in Block Island?

CohostAI turns these recommendations into a guest guide for your exact address — and answers your guests' questions from it, day or night, in their language.

Build my AI cohost

Free to start. No credit card required.

Nearby Guides

Watch Hill, RI29 kmWesterly, RI32 kmNarragansett, RI32 kmMontauk, NY37 kmJamestown, RI39 kmMystic, CT40 kmNewport, RI41 kmWickford, RI45 km

Want more hosting tips? Check out our blog for guides on earning 5-star reviews, creating house manuals, and more.

Things to Do in Block Island, RI — 27 Local Picks | CohostAI