Paolucci Restaurant & Lounge
italian
An Italian-American family institution downtown, with roots in a fruit market generations back, plating homemade lasagna and chicken parmesan. The attached deli counter is where locals actually grab the famous subs and BLTs to go.
2 local tips
- Hit the deli counter for the BLT and Italian subs to take out
- Ask about the family's long history if you want the backstory
Pete's Steak House
american
A Greek-owned steakhouse going strong for decades, hand-cutting locally sourced steaks alongside homemade pastas, soups, and a few Greek touches. The Greek-style dishes are the sleeper pick most people miss.
2 local tips
- Ask for steaks cooked to order rather than the default
- Try a Greek-style menu item; it is the underrated half of the menu
A family-run Mexican restaurant built on grandparents' recipes, with the warmest stack of positive reviews of any kitchen in town and gluten-free options on hand. Ask which dishes came straight from the old family cookbook.
2 local tips
- Closed Sundays, so plan around it
- Ask the staff which plates are the original family recipes
Willie's Sports Pub
american
A locally loved sports pub on Commercial Street where the grilled pork tenderloin sandwich is the order, with burgers and spinach dip rounding it out. A good spot to land in a Benedictine College game crowd.
2 local tips
- Get the grilled pork tenderloin sandwich
- Lively when there is a college game on
A next-generation revival of a long-gone local diner, serving home-style lunches and homemade pies made fresh daily. The weekly traditions, chicken and noodles early in the week, pan-fried chicken later, are what regulars come for.
2 local tips
- Go Monday for chicken and noodles or Thursday for pan-fried chicken
- Save room for a slice of pie, the real draw
Maria's Mexican Restaurant
mexican
A Commercial Street Mexican spot that ranks among the town's favorites for sit-down fare, on the same block as the pubs. An easy alternative when the busier Mexican kitchen has a wait.
2 local tips
- A handy backup if Lopez has a line; same downtown block
- Closed Sundays
A friendly diner over on Main Street for breakfast, brunch, sandwiches, and homemade soups, made to order and easy on the wallet. A locals' morning spot away from the downtown core.
2 local tips
- Breakfast and the sandwiches are the move
- It sits on Main Street, off the main tourist drag
The town's espresso-and-pastry spot, with homemade quiche, scones, cinnamon rolls, and a jalapeño-cheddar breakfast sandwich on a pretzel bun. The back rooms double as study nooks for Benedictine students.
2 local tips
- Order the jalapeño-cheddar pretzel-bun breakfast sandwich
- It is a morning and lunch place; closed Sundays and shuts mid-afternoon
Downtown's wine bar, with a curated list plus craft cocktails, whiskeys, and small bites in a historic Commercial Street building. It is the grown-up evening counterpoint to the town's brewery scene.
2 local tips
- The most adult evening-drink option in the downtown core
- Pair a visit with a stroll of the historic Commercial Street blocks