Pike and Pint Grill
american★ 4.4(412)
The long-running local standard-bearer for a proper dinner out in Alexandria — a full-service grill and bar that pairs hand-crafted plates with regional craft beers and a solid cocktail list. The walleye and the hand-cut ribeye are the things to order, and the bar side gets lively on weekend evenings. Voted best restaurant in the lakes area by the local paper's readers in back-to-back years, and the reviews hold up.
3 local tips
- The craft-burger lineup runs beyond beef to bison and walleye patties — a lighter alternative when you don't want a full steak dinner.
- The bar half of the room takes walk-ins even when the dining room is reserved; the same full menu applies.
- Parking is in the lot behind the building off 30th Ave West; street spots out front are usually taken by 6pm.
A family-owned Mexican grill on the 30th Avenue West commercial strip, and the spot locals point to when they want Mexican in Alexandria. The kitchen runs the full range of combination platters, enchiladas, and sizzling fajitas, with a full bar and the complimentary chips and house salsa that regulars single out. Festive and unfussy, with fast service that suits a family dinner or a quick weeknight table.
3 local tips
- The complimentary chips and house-made salsa are a genuine draw — regulars mention them as much as the entrees.
- It's a full-bar spot; the margaritas pair well with the combination platters if you're settling in for a longer dinner.
- It sits on the 30th Avenue West strip near Pike and Pint, an easy west-side stop rather than a downtown one.
DJ's Tap House & Grill
american★ 4.5(143)
A locals-loved burger-and-craft-beer institution on the south side of Alexandria, with 30-plus taps and Black Angus beef handcrafted into some of the best burgers in the lakes area. The lahvosh flatbreads and cheese curds are the appetizers to order, and the patio is the spot in good weather. Reliably packed with actual Alexandria residents, not resort tourists — which is the best indicator of a place worth going to.
3 local tips
- The vegetarian burger has a loyal following and deserves to be ordered on its own merits, not just as a fallback.
- Tap selections rotate frequently; ask the bartender what just came on rather than defaulting to the printed list.
- The patio has better service flow than the main room — request it when weather allows.
Longtrees Woodfire Grill
american★ 4.6(64)
A wood-fire grill that relocated downtown into The Rune, its purpose-built Broadway space with two patios and a central fire for gathering. Steaks and rotisserie chicken roast over an open flame, and the Midwest-inspired menu leans on locally sourced and foraged ingredients, now alongside a full craft-cocktail list. The kitchen runs more supper-club than gastropub — and it's walkable from the rest of downtown rather than the old drive south of town.
3 local tips
- The wood-fired rotisserie chicken and open-flame steaks are the signature — the kitchen is built around that live fire.
- The Broadway space has two patios — one for open-air dining, one with lawn games and a central fire — best on a warm evening.
- It moved from its old Highway 29 spot into The Rune downtown, so it's now a short walk from the other Broadway stops.
Traveler's Inn
american★ 4.5(198)
A diner institution on Broadway open since 1925 and still serving scratch breakfasts and lunch classics to a mix of retirees, resort workers, and everyone else in between. The caramel rolls and pie are made in-house daily, and the portions are the kind that leave you set until dinner. If you want to understand what feeds Alexandria before it wakes up, sit at the counter here on a Tuesday morning.
3 local tips
- The pies are a genuine draw — grab a slice with coffee rather than treating dessert as an afterthought.
- Breakfast and lunch only, closed by mid-afternoon; plan accordingly.
- Cash-friendly and card-accepted; the line moves quickly even when it looks long.
Northwoods Cafe
brunch★ 4.6(72)
A no-frills breakfast and lunch spot on 3rd Avenue East where the food is straightforward, the portions are substantial, and the locals-to-visitors ratio strongly favors locals. Eggs, omelets, skillets, and daily specials made the way they've always been made — nothing trendy, nothing disappointing. The kind of place where regulars have a usual order and the staff already knows it.
3 local tips
- The daily homemade lunch specials — soup, hot dish, and a sandwich combo — are better value than the breakfast menu if you're arriving after 11am.
- The room is small; a short wait is common on weekend mornings, but the line moves fast.
- Cash is appreciated; bring it.
BNC's Cafe
brunch★ 4.5(40)
A newer family-run breakfast-all-day cafe on 3rd Avenue West that opened to immediate local enthusiasm — the cinnamon French toast and generously portioned skillets are the standouts. It fills a gap in Alexandria's morning landscape: a bright, unhurried room where you can linger over coffee and eggs without competing with the resort crowd. The staff hustle and the prices are refreshingly reasonable.
3 local tips
- The cinnamon French toast is the signature — it's thicker and more custardy than it looks on the menu description.
- They open early on weekdays; a great stop before hitting the Central Lakes Trail.
- Gets busy on weekend mornings; arrive at or just after opening to skip the wait.
Copper Trail Brewing Co
american★ 4.8(35)
Alexandria's downtown taproom in a historic Broadway building, with about 24 rotating taps and a 205 Grill kitchen known for elevated bar food — corned beef sandwiches, artisanal small plates, and a seasonal patio with fire pits that runs late into warm evenings. The craft beer program is the genuine article: a range of styles that rewards experimentation rather than just drinking what's familiar. A strong evening anchor in a town that needs one.
3 local tips
- The 205 Grill menu changes seasonally; the rotating artisanal plates are consistently stronger than the standard pub-food standbys.
- The fire-pit patio seats are first-come; arrive by 5:30pm on weekends if you want one.
- Beer flights are available — ask for the current draft list rather than the printed one, which lags behind new arrivals.