Casey's Caboose
american★ 4.6(390)
A Killington institution since 1981, Casey's is the kind of restaurant that locals and return visitors claim ownership of. The menu runs from steak and seafood to loaded mac and cheese and burgers, the fireplace crackles in winter, and the après-ski happy hour is one of the best-value windows on the Access Road. Rustic in the best sense.
2 local tips
- The happy hour from 3-5pm has the best food-value proposition on the Access Road
- Get a fireplace-adjacent table by arriving when they open — they fill immediately on ski days
The Foundry at Summit Pond
american★ 4.2(720)
A restaurant built on the banks of Summit Pond that earns its reputation as Killington's most scenically situated dining room. The menu aims higher than most resort-area spots — braised short rib, Vermont cheese boards, seasonal mushroom risotto — with a wine list that reflects real effort. Summer patio dining on the pond edge is genuinely lovely.
2 local tips
- The sunset-facing patio on summer evenings is worth a reservation specifically — request it when booking
- The Vermont cheese board changes with the seasons; ask your server which local producers are currently featured
McGrath's Irish Pub
american★ 4.4(293)
Set inside the Inn at Long Trail right where Route 4 meets the Appalachian Trail, McGrath's is a proper Irish pub with Guinness on tap, live Irish music on weekends, and shepherd's pie that actually tastes like someone's grandmother made it. The hiking crowd mixes with ski-season visitors in a room that feels genuinely transported from Cork.
2 local tips
- Live Irish music runs Friday and Saturday — get there by 7pm for a seat near the session
- The Long Trail Ale and Guinness share equal status here; try the half-and-half if undecided
Choices Restaurant & Rotisserie
american★ 4.2(245)
A Killington standby that has been feeding the resort community for over 35 years with a menu broader than almost anyone else on the Access Road — rotisserie meats, fresh pasta, seafood, and homemade burgers alongside a proper bar. It's consistently dependable in a market where consistency matters.
2 local tips
- The rotisserie chicken is the dish that regulars keep returning for — get it with the roasted vegetables
- It books out on Saturday evenings in peak season; weeknights are easier
Lookout Tavern
american★ 4.2(294)
A sports bar and tavern on the Access Road with a rooftop deck, seasonal pool, and the kind of pub-menu-plus-game-on-every-screen vibe that earns its place in a ski town. The food goes beyond bar snacks — flatbreads, decent wings, and burgers — without trying to be a serious restaurant. Honest about what it is.
2 local tips
- The rooftop deck is open in warm weather only — confirm before making it the destination
- Busy on college ski weekends; families tend to have a better time mid-week
Wobbly Barn Steakhouse
american★ 4.0(286)
One of Killington's longest-running operations, the Wobbly Barn has been the après-ski landmark on the Access Road since 1963. The steakhouse kitchen serves hand-selected Angus beef aged a minimum of 21 days, alongside seasonal dishes and live music most nights. It functions simultaneously as a serious steakhouse and one of the area's busiest bars.
2 local tips
- The bar is a separate experience from the dining room — you can access the music without booking a dinner table
- Prime cuts need advance reservation on peak ski weekends; the bar is always available for drinks and appetizers
Garlic Restaurant
italian★ 4.2(230)
An Italian-leaning restaurant on the Access Road that takes its name seriously — garlic features prominently across a menu of pasta, brick-oven pizza, and classic Italian-American preparations. The room is warm and casual, the portions are resort-generous, and it's a reliable option when the après-ski crowd thins to actual dinner.
2 local tips
- The brick-oven pizza is a better bet than the pasta on busy nights when the kitchen is stretched
- Midweek visits let the kitchen show better care with the more complex pasta dishes
Sugar and Spice Restaurant
brunch★ 4.5(540)
A breakfast institution on Route 4 in Mendon, between Killington and Rutland, operating out of a working sugarhouse that produces its own maple syrup. Pancakes, French toast, and waffles here are dressed with syrup that came from the trees surrounding the building. It's the real article — not a maple-themed restaurant, an actual sugar operation.
2 local tips
- Arrive before 9am — it's small, popular, and the wait grows quickly after that
- The maple creemee is a Vermont soft-serve tradition; get one on the way out regardless of season