The Belfry
american★ 4.5(312)
Set inside a former early-1900s schoolhouse in Montgomery Center, this pub serves burgers, pasta, and seafood to a crowd that ranges from locals to ski-weary resort guests. The bar is warm and unpretentious, and the après-ski vibe stretches well into the evening. It fills up on weekends in ski season, so arrive early or expect a wait.
3 local tips
- Arrive before 6 pm on winter weekends to avoid a long wait — reservations are not always taken
- The bar seats are first-come and a good spot to chat with locals who ski Jay regularly
- The onion soup and Vermont beef burger are the reliable orders here
The Black Lantern Inn Restaurant
american★ 4.7(138)
An 1803 stagecoach stop turned inn dining room, this place in Montgomery Village serves thoughtfully prepared seasonal Vermont cuisine in a cozy, candlelit setting. The menu rotates with what is local and available, and the atmosphere feels more like a dinner party than a restaurant. Reservations are strongly advised — it is small and fills up.
3 local tips
- Reserve ahead, especially on weekends; this is a small room and walk-ins are often turned away
- Ask about the Vermont cheese board for a starter that showcases local creameries
- The inn's wraparound porch is worth a look before or after dinner if the weather cooperates
The Foundry at Stateside
american★ 4.4(106)
Located slope-side at Jay Peak Resort, The Foundry covers all bases with wood-fired pizza, Vermont craft beers on tap, and more polished dinner plates for those who want something beyond pub fare. It is the most convenient dinner option if you are staying on the mountain without a car, and the bar stays lively on ski nights. The wood-fired oven is the centerpiece and does good work.
3 local tips
- The wood-fired pizza is the standout — stick to that over the more ambitious dinner plates
- Grab a spot at the bar for faster service on crowded ski-season evenings
- Happy hour pricing on drafts applies in the early post-ski window, usually 3–5 pm
Omakase at the Tavern
asian★ 4.6(71)
A genuinely surprising find tucked into a historic tavern building in Montgomery Center, this small restaurant serves Asian fusion in a setting where you would not expect it. The menu is tightly edited and changes with what the kitchen feels like doing, so the experience shifts visit to visit. It draws regulars from both the ski crowd and locals who appreciate something different.
3 local tips
- Check their social media or call ahead because hours and menu availability shift seasonally
- Seating is very limited, so treat this as a reservation-essential dinner rather than a drop-in
- The sake and cocktail selection is better than you would expect this far from a city
The Eastside Restaurant & Pub
seafood★ 4.3(381)
Perched on the shore of Lake Memphremagog in Newport, this lakeside pub serves American classics and fresh seafood with views over the water that stretch into Canada. It is the most atmospheric dining room in Newport, and on a summer evening the deck is excellent. The fish and the lake view together are the reason to make the drive into town.
3 local tips
- Request a table on the deck for the best lake views — worth specifying when you reserve
- Sunday brunch draws a local crowd and the lines move well
- Newport is about 25 minutes from Jay Peak so pair this with other Newport errands to make the trip count
Inside the Jay Cloud Cyclery in Montgomery Center, this cafe turns out house-made pastries, breakfast sandwiches, and strong coffee alongside a bike shop full of Vermont maps and trail beta. It is where locals start their mornings, and the space has an easy community feel that carries into the summer music events held outside. The töstis are a house specialty worth ordering.
3 local tips
- The muffins and pastries sell out early on weekends, so come before 9 am if that is your goal
- The bike shop staff doubles as excellent local trail and road guides for the area
- Check for live music nights in summer which turn the parking area into a casual outdoor venue
Brown Cow Restaurant
brunch★ 4.3(182)
A Newport breakfast and lunch institution that locals have relied on for no-nonsense home-style cooking at honest prices. Pancakes, eggs, and sandwiches done right in a small, friendly room where the staff knows the regulars. Nothing complicated, nothing disappointing — just a reliable diner in a town that needs one.
3 local tips
- Weekend mornings see a wait, so arrive by 8 am or plan for 10 am when the first rush clears
- The pancakes and hash are the draws — straightforward but executed well
- Cash is preferred and the menu is tight, which keeps everything fresh
INN Restaurant & Bar at Jay Peak
american★ 4.2(215)
The main sit-down dining room at Jay Peak Resort, this restaurant handles everything from breakfast to dinner with a menu that leans on Vermont sourcing and comfort-oriented dishes. It is the most reliable full-service option on the mountain, particularly for families who do not want to drive after a ski day. The bar program is solid and the view from the dining room of the slopes is a nice touch.
3 local tips
- Breakfast here before the lifts open is efficient and the kitchen handles a crowd well
- The locally sourced Vermont dishes on the dinner menu are generally better than the more generic items
- Hotel guests get priority seating at peak times, so reservations are worth making if you are staying off-site