Moon and Turtle
seafood★ 4.5(854)
A tiny, intimate restaurant on Kalakaua Street run by a Hilo-native kitchen whose daily-changing menu is built entirely on what's available from the Hilo Farmers Market and local fishermen that morning. The space seats under 30 people and the cooking has a precision that would be notable in any city. Reserve well ahead; this is the most sought-after table on the east side of the Big Island.
3 local tips
- Reservations fill fast — book as soon as your travel dates are confirmed.
- The daily-changing menu means you cannot plan what you will eat; trust the kitchen and order whatever the server describes as that night's focus.
- The wine list is small and thoughtfully chosen; ask for the natural wine section if it appeals.
Suisan Fish Market
seafood★ 4.5(779)
The definitive poke spot in Hilo — a fish market adjacent to the commercial fishing docks where the ahi and tuna are processed on-site at maximum freshness. The poke cases offer a dozen or more preparations including spicy ahi, classic shoyu, yuzu scallop, and garlic butter prawn, all sold by the cup at prices that make you wonder what you've been paying elsewhere.
3 local tips
- Go early — lines form before 11am and specific preparations sell out by early afternoon.
- The cups are portioned to eat standing up; walk to the harbor dock nearby for the proper poke-by-the-water experience.
- The ahi quality is directly tied to what came off the boats that morning; the freshest cut is the easiest to identify by color.
Kawamoto Store
asian★ 4.6(335)
A glass-case deli on Kilauea Avenue that serves Japanese, Filipino, Hawaiian, and Chinese prepared foods in the bento tradition — tempura, nori chicken, spam musubi, cone sushi, nishime, and weekly specials in portions sized for people with actual appetites. Custom bento boxes are assembled to order. This is the kind of place that exists in Hawaii and nowhere else, where the multicultural history of plantation-era labor has produced a cuisine entirely its own.
3 local tips
- The custom bento format lets you pick three to five items from the case into a box — the tempura and the nori chicken are the anchors.
- Cash is preferred and faster; the line moves quickly if you know what you want.
- Pack the bento and walk to Liliuokalani Gardens or Coconut Island for the best possible cheap lunch in Hilo.
Pineapples Island Fresh Cuisine
american★ 4.5(2,603)
The only open-air restaurant in downtown Hilo, with a farm-to-table menu anchored by local fish, pineapple fried rice, and coconut-crusted fresh catch. Live entertainment runs Tuesday through Sunday evenings, which makes this a natural dinner stop for visitors who want the Hilo social experience alongside food. The cocktails use local tropical fruit and are better than most comparable spots on the island.
3 local tips
- The evening entertainment schedule is on their website; Tuesday through Sunday are the live music nights.
- The fresh catch preparation changes daily; ask what fish came in that day and order it in whatever preparation the server recommends.
- The open-air setting is comfortable in Hilo's climate but brings rain with it — the covered sections fill first.
Jackie Rey's Ohana Grill
american★ 4.5(1,264)
A casual local's restaurant in the historic 1907 Kaikodo building on Keawe Street — the original English bar and the bank vault turned private dining space make the room one of Hilo's most interesting. The menu is anchored by fresh fish that arrives at the back door daily from local boats, never frozen, with the clam chowder, kalua pork spring rolls, and lobster ravioli among the kitchen's consistent winners.
3 local tips
- Happy hour is the best time to experience the room's energy and the freshness of the fish at lower prices.
- The building is easy to walk past; look for the historic facade on Keawe Street.
- The daily fish preparation is worth asking about regardless of what else looks appealing on the menu.
Ken's House of Pancakes
brunch★ 4.4(2,892)
A Hilo institution since 1971, open around the clock, where the loco moco — a signature Big Island dish of rice, hamburger patty, fried egg, and brown gravy — reaches a form that many locals consider definitive. The sumo loco moco with Spam adds another layer of Hawaii food culture, and the banana macadamia pancakes are substantial enough to anchor the whole meal.
3 local tips
- The late-night and early-morning hours are when the authentic local crowd dominates; the mid-morning tourist window is busier.
- Order the classic loco moco before experimenting with variations — the baseline version is the reason the place has been open for five decades.
- Cash speeds things up; the place is large but moves quickly even when busy.
Naung Mai Thai Kitchen
asian★ 4.4(451)
A modest Thai restaurant near the Hilo Farmers Market that sources organic and local ingredients from the same vendors that supply the market, producing Thai cooking with more flavor complexity than its stripped-down setting suggests. The massaman curry and pad see ew are the kitchen's strongest suits. Among Hilo's Thai options, Naung Mai consistently gets the locals' recommendation.
3 local tips
- The lunch hours are less crowded than dinner; the kitchen is at its best when not slammed.
- The organic and local sourcing means seasonal variations in the menu; ask what's coming from the market that week.
- The room is small and simple with no particular ambiance — it is purely about the food.
Two Ladies Kitchen
dessert★ 4.7(1,503)
A tiny hole-in-the-wall on Kilauea Avenue that makes fresh mochi to order — Japanese rice-flour confections wrapped around fresh fruit, with the strawberry mochi considered the best in all of Hawaii by a significant contingent of regular visitors and local judges. The operation is minimal: a small counter, a few flavors daily, and a line that forms before they open. Closed Mondays.
3 local tips
- Arrive before noon; the mochi is made fresh and sells out by early afternoon most days, and the strawberry version goes fastest.
- The shop is on Kilauea Avenue and easy to drive past; look for the line of people standing outside.
- Bring a cooler or insulated bag if you want to take mochi back to your accommodation — best eaten the same day.
Cafe Pesto Hilo Bay
italian★ 4.3(1,859)
A 30-year bayfront institution in the historic S. Hata Building on Kamehameha Avenue, serving wood-fired pizzas, housemade pasta, and seafood dishes that blend Italian technique with Big Island ingredients. The room is one of the more atmospheric in Hilo — original architecture, bay views from corner tables, and a family-friendly pace that makes it work for long lunches.
3 local tips
- The corner tables by the windows face Hilo Bay; ask for one when you book.
- The lunch service is calmer and often better-paced than dinner; the wood-fired pizzas are available all day.
- The happy hour includes discounted appetizers and house sangria that locals use as a pre-dinner stop.
Puka Puka Kitchen
middle_eastern★ 4.4(517)
A downtown Hilo counter that does something genuinely unusual — an eclectic daily menu mixing Hawaiian, Japanese, Indian, and Middle Eastern preparations that consistently works. Ahi don, falafel pitas, chicken katsu, miso mahi, and garlic lamb share the menu without irony, all made from locally sourced ingredients at prices that reflect Hilo's cost structure rather than its ambition.
3 local tips
- The menu changes based on what's available; don't be surprised if your previous visit's standout dish is gone.
- The lamb with garlic rice is the sleeper item if it's available — ask specifically.
- Cash is preferred; the setup is fast-casual with counter ordering.
Kula Shave Ice
dessert★ 4.8(433)
A shave ice stand next to the Hilo Farmers Market using handcrafted organic syrups without artificial dyes or preservatives — the haupia (coconut cream) base and lilikoi syrup combination is what regulars order, and the strawberry with condensed milk drizzle runs a close second. Reviewers from across the islands consider this among the finest shave ice anywhere.
3 local tips
- Get it with the haupia base layer rather than skipping it — the cream underneath changes the whole experience.
- The stand is right by the Hilo Farmers Market on Mamo Street; combine the two on a Wednesday or Saturday morning.
- Family-friendly and fast; the line moves quickly even when it looks long.