The Forks Restaurant & Inn
american★ 4.7(410)
A dinner-only restaurant perched above the Tygart Valley River, ranked #1 in Elkins, with a menu of steaks, fresh salads, and carefully sourced local ingredients in a setting that genuinely earns its countryside-drive reputation. The Inn rooms upstairs make it a convenient base if you're spending several days exploring the forest. Thursday through Sunday only — plan ahead.
3 local tips
- Reservations are essential on weekends; the small dining room fills with both locals celebrating and forest visitors who've done their research.
- Ask about the daily specials — the kitchen sources locally and the off-menu preparations often outperform the printed options.
- The river views from the dining room are best at dusk; time your reservation accordingly in summer.
El Gran Sabor
latin★ 4.5(154)
A Venezuelan-Latin kitchen on Kerens Avenue that doubles as a live music venue on weekends, with generous plates of arepas, empanadas, and grilled meats at prices that make the quality feel almost implausible for a city this size. The bar in the back gets lively on weekend nights with local bands, while the front dining room stays relaxed enough for a proper sit-down meal. Open Wednesday through Saturday only.
3 local tips
- The combination plate lets you try multiple Venezuelan specialties at once — a good first-visit strategy if you don't know the menu well.
- The weekend live music in the back bar is free to join; it attracts a genuine local crowd rather than tourists.
- They sometimes run out of popular items before closing — arrive in the first half of service for the full menu.
Smoke on the Water BBQ
american★ 4.4(142)
An eastern-route BBQ joint on Allegheny Highway with a patio setting along a creek and a straightforward smoked meats menu — pulled pork, ribs, brisket — done with real wood smoke. Ranked second in Elkins on TripAdvisor, it's the go-to for locals who want BBQ without driving to Charleston. Wednesday through Sunday service only, which means weekend arrivals should go early.
3 local tips
- The patio along the creek is the best seat in the house in good weather; request it when you call ahead.
- Sides sell out on busy Saturdays — arrive at the start of lunch service for the full complement of housemade options.
- The pulled pork sandwich is the best value on the menu; the ribs require more patience and are better for slow, unhurried visits.
Byrd's House of Donuts
dessert★ 4.8(138)
A small-batch donut shop on Davis Avenue with a cult following among Elkins locals for made-fresh-daily yeasted donuts, cream-filled pastries, and seasonal pie slices. The case sells out most days before noon — this is not a place to visit at 11 AM and expect a full selection. Rated 4.8 on TripAdvisor, which for a small-town donut shop indicates a genuinely special operation.
3 local tips
- Arrive before 9 AM for the full selection; by mid-morning the cream donuts are usually gone.
- The coconut pie (when available) is the sleeper item that regulars return for — ask the counter staff what they'd personally recommend.
- It's cash-friendly and the staff are quick, making it a good pre-hike first stop on your way to the forest.
Beander's Restaurant & Tavern
american★ 4.4(543)
A longtime Davis Avenue bar and grill with a broad comfort-food menu, a pool table, and a local crowd that keeps it humming on weeknight evenings. Rated 4.4 on Google with over 1,200 reviews across platforms — unusually well-reviewed for a pub this size — the food runs to wings, burgers, and sandwiches done with more care than the casual setting would suggest. A reliable evening option when The Forks is booked.
3 local tips
- The wings are the consistent crowd-pleaser; order a batch alongside any other main and you won't regret it.
- The bar fills up on Friday evenings when locals decompress after the week — earlier dinner reservations are calmer.
- Check whether live music is scheduled; Beander's occasionally hosts acoustic acts that make an otherwise ordinary bar night feel more like an event.
Big Timber Brewing Company
american★ 4.5(150)
Elkins's downtown craft brewery, housed in a renovated space on Davis Avenue with a stone fireplace and a patio overlooking the Tygart Valley River. The taproom specializes in rotating small-batch beers and has an attached food menu of flatbreads and pub snacks sized for sharing over pints. Their porter won a world-level competition, and the patio is one of the better outdoor spots in the city for an afternoon drink.
3 local tips
- The outdoor patio fills fast on summer evenings after 5 PM — arrive by 4 PM to claim a good river-view spot.
- Ask what's newest on tap; the brewery rotates frequently and the most recent batches aren't always posted on the website.
- The taproom often hosts acoustic musicians on weekends — check their social media before your visit.
Gandy Dancer Theatre and Conference Center
american★ 4.6(1,114)
West Virginia's only Branson-style dinner theatre, on Beverly Pike outside downtown Elkins, combining a full buffet dinner with a live country and gospel variety show performed by a rotating cast of multi-instrumentalists. It seats several hundred and runs a family-friendly two-hour production that pulls in both tourists and locals who keep coming back seasonally. Ranked #1 of things to do in Elkins on TripAdvisor.
3 local tips
- The specialty shows — Elvis tribute nights, murder mystery dinners, Christmas productions — book out further in advance than the regular shows; reserve those early.
- The buffet opens before the show; arriving right at opening gives you time to eat comfortably before the performance begins.
- Front-center table section has the best sightlines; mention it when booking and they'll accommodate if possible.