Milo's Cafe & Restaurant
brunch★ 4.5(168)
The anchor dining room of the Bright Morning Inn in downtown Davis, serving a breakfast that won Best Breakfast Sandwich in West Virginia and has sustained a loyal regional following since. The kitchen operates from the first floor of the renovated lumberjack boardinghouse, now expanded to serve dinner nightly — though breakfast remains the reason most visitors make the pilgrimage.
3 local tips
- Breakfast is served four mornings a week; confirm the current schedule before planning around it.
- The breakfast sandwich that won the state award is still on the menu — order it before considering alternatives.
- Dinner service is a more recent addition; the kitchen is most practiced in its morning and midday cooking.
Hellbender Burritos
mexican★ 4.2(462)
A beloved counter-service burrito shop in downtown Davis where the portions are legendary and the ingredients are fresh — reviewers reliably describe the burritos as among the largest they've ever encountered at reasonable prices. The small space gets crowded at peak times and there's an upstairs waiting area, making this the quintessential post-trail comfort meal for the Blackwater Falls and Canaan Valley crowd.
3 local tips
- The burritos are genuinely large — one is a full meal for most people even after a full day of hiking.
- Hours run Thursday through Sunday (closed early in the week); the compact space backs up at weekend lunch, so order ahead by phone when you can.
- Parking on William Avenue gets tight on peak weekends; the lot a block over provides easier access.
Purple Fiddle
american★ 4.5(280)
A deli-style kitchen and bar inside the Purple Fiddle music venue in Thomas, where the food keeps pace with the music programming — fresh, unpretentious, and made to sustain an evening. The kitchen turns out sandwiches, soups, and bar snacks that fuel the crowd between sets, with cold beer on tap and a warm atmosphere that makes it one of the most genuinely welcoming venues in the region.
3 local tips
- The music starts at 9pm on Fridays and Saturdays; arrive by 8pm to get a table and order food before the room fills.
- Kids under 12 are admitted free to all shows when a cover applies — it's a family-friendly venue despite the bar setting.
- Free afternoon shows run on Saturdays and Sundays around 1pm; a good option for visitors who don't want a late night.
Sirianni's Cafe
italian★ 4.1(585)
A cash-only Italian pizza and pasta spot in downtown Davis with an old-school diner-adjacent atmosphere and a loyal local following built over decades. The pizza is the main event — thin-crust, generously topped, and made by a kitchen that has been doing it long enough to have its own style. The wait times during peak season are real, but so is the reason for them.
3 local tips
- Cash or check only — there's an ATM on-site now if you arrive without cash.
- During peak summer and fall weekends, waits of 45 minutes to an hour are not unusual; arrive before 6pm.
- The pizza is the anchor; the Italian pasta dishes are decent but secondary to why regulars keep coming back.
ISH Kitchen at The Billy
american★ 4.5(85)
The restaurant at The Billy Motel in Davis, reopened in 2022 after a remodel that added a new dining room and full bar. Branded ISH Kitchen, it trades standard mountain fare for a globally inspired menu that can pull small plates from as many as eight countries in a single week — Portuguese cheese puffs, Spanish patatas bravas, Vietnamese grape-leaf rolls, Thai panang curry — served in the motel's stylish retro setting.
3 local tips
- The menu is built around globally inspired small plates; order several to share across the table rather than one entree each.
- The dining room at The Billy is quieter and more spacious than most Davis options — good for a longer, more relaxed meal.
- There's a full bar now — it works as well for a drink and a few plates as for a full dinner; reservations help on busy weekends.
Canaan Valley BBQ
american★ 4.3(180)
A wood-smoked barbecue operation in the Canaan Valley area serving pulled pork, brisket, and smoked chicken to the resort and outdoor recreation crowd that passes through. The portions are built for post-ski and post-hike hunger and the kitchen sources locally within the region, giving the food a West Virginia character rather than mimicking a standard national BBQ template.
3 local tips
- The smoked meats sell out by mid-afternoon on busy weekends; plan a lunch visit rather than dinner.
- Sides are house-made and change based on what's available; ask what's on rotation rather than defaulting to standards.
- The outdoor seating area is the better choice in good weather; the indoor space can fill quickly after resort closes.
Wicked Wilderness Pub
american★ 4.3(210)
A pub and kitchen in downtown Davis that has carved out a reputation among locals for a beer selection that goes well beyond what the mountain surroundings would suggest, paired with pub food made with care. The atmosphere is relaxed and communal in the way small mountain town bars tend to be, with regulars who are locals mixed with hikers and recreationists who found their way in.
3 local tips
- The tap selection rotates with West Virginia and regional craft brewers; ask what's new rather than defaulting to the usual suspects.
- Kitchen closes earlier than the bar; arrive by 9pm to reliably get food.
- The outdoor patio sees use well into September; worth knowing about on warm evenings when the indoor space feels tight.
Happy & More Bakery & Cafe
cafe★ 4.5(150)
A from-scratch bakery and breakfast cafe on Thomas's WV-32 strip, known for cinnamon rolls made with cream and vanilla bean alongside cakes, pies, and cookies. The short menu also runs to savory omelets, breakfast sandwiches, and pastries — a dependable morning stop for the Thomas gallery crowd and hikers heading toward Blackwater or Dolly Sods.
3 local tips
- Open Thursday through Monday, roughly 8am to 2pm — a morning-and-midday stop, not a dinner option.
- The scratch cinnamon rolls are the signature and can sell out, so come earlier rather than later.
- It sits in Thomas on WV-32, an easy add-on to a Front Street gallery walk or a Purple Fiddle afternoon show.