A downtown kitchen from Cody-native chef Nathan Kardos that leans on regional ranchers and a wood-fired oven, with a menu shifting from bison bolognese and elk medallions to scratch pasta and pizza. It is where locals go when they want a real dinner rather than a tourist photo.
3 local tips
- The menu changes with what is in season, so ask the server what came in that week rather than ordering off muscle memory.
- It draws a steady local dinner crowd, so a weekend reservation saves you a wait.
- The wood-fired pizzas are a quieter-night move if you do not want a full sit-down dinner.
8th Street at the Ivy
american
The closest thing in Cody to a white-tablecloth dinner, set inside the Ivy Inn a few blocks from the Buffalo Bill Center. The kitchen does contemporary American plates with a local wine and craft-beer list, and regulars rate the brussels sprouts and old fashioneds.
3 local tips
- This is the special-occasion pick in town, so reserve a dinner table on summer weekends.
- It serves both breakfast and dinner but closes the mid-afternoon, so it is not a lunch plan.
- Sit in the dining room rather than the bar if you want the quieter, view-facing side.
New Mexican rather than Tex-Mex, run by the same owner for more than two decades right on the main drag. The green chile and the house salsa are what regulars come back for, and the steak fajitas hold up.
3 local tips
- Order anything with the green chile; it is the kitchen's signature and travels well as a side.
- It fills fast in the dinner window during summer, so go early or late to skip the wait.
- Ask for extra of the house salsa up front since tables go through it quickly.
The Cody Steakhouse
american
A downtown steakhouse with country music setting the tone and a kitchen that turns out solid cuts plus buffalo ribeye without the special-occasion price of bigger steak rooms. Good for a dinner that feels like an occasion without planning ahead.
3 local tips
- Save room for the desserts, which regulars rate higher than the menu lets on.
- It keeps short evening hours and is closed early in the week, so check before you head over.
- Tables turn slowly on weekend nights once the music starts, so arrive hungry and unhurried.
Shiki Japanese Restaurant
asian
Japanese-owned and the only real sushi in town for over a decade, with rolls plus chef specials that use local game like buffalo sirloin tataki. An unexpected find this far from a coast, and the regulars know it.
3 local tips
- The chef specials beyond the standard roll list are where the kitchen shows off, so ask what is fresh.
- Seating is limited and it draws a loyal crowd, so a weekend wait is normal.
- Skip the fried-rice-style sides and lean into the raw and tataki dishes.
A small family-run Thai kitchen that moved to Cody from nearby Ralston and built a following on curries, noodle plates, and genuine heat. Order the spice level you actually want and they will deliver it.
3 local tips
- Tell them how hot you really want it; the default tends to be tuned down for the local palate.
- Portions run generous, so the curries make good next-day leftovers.
- It is a small room that gets busy at peak dinner, so call ahead for takeout on weekends.
A veteran-owned smokehouse on Sheridan that has been turning out brisket and ribs since the mid-2010s and once landed on a best-BBQ-in-Wyoming list. Come for the smoked meats by weight rather than overthinking the sides.
3 local tips
- Popular cuts sell out on busy summer days, so going earlier in the service window is safer for brisket.
- Order by the meat first and let the sides be an afterthought; the smoke is the draw.
- Seating is casual and limited, so it works well as a takeout pickup.
Millstone Pizza Company & Brewery
italian
A roomy downtown tavern making its own beer alongside a pizza list that ranges from a Thai-influenced pie to solid gluten-free crusts. The laid-back booths and arcade make it an easy stop with a group or kids.
3 local tips
- The gluten-free pizza is genuinely good here, which is rare, so it is a safe call for mixed groups.
- Try the Thai pizza if you want something off the standard pepperoni track.
- It is one of the more spacious rooms downtown, so it absorbs a wait better than the smaller spots.
Cody's neighborhood brewpub, formerly Pat O'Hara Brewing, now the only all-female-owned brewery in Wyoming, pouring a dozen-plus house taps next to Irish-leaning American pub food. The regulars treat it more like a clubhouse than a tourist stop.
3 local tips
- Order a flight to taste across the house lineup before committing to a pint.
- It keeps a tighter weekly schedule than downtown spots, so confirm the days it is open.
- The pub plates are built for pairing with beer, so come hungry rather than expecting light bites.
A genuine cowboy saloon on Sheridan with taxidermy on the walls and a menu built on steaks, burgers, and a French dip people drive in for. It leans Western-kitsch but the kitchen backs it up more often than not.
3 local tips
- The French dip with sweet potato fries is the order locals point newcomers to.
- Steak quality can swing, so the steak salad and sandwiches are the safer bets on a busy night.
- The bar side is the better seat if you want the saloon atmosphere over a quiet table.
A family-run lunch counter and old-time soda fountain doing fresh soups, paninis, and ice cream floats in a cozy room downtown. It is the easy midday break between museum and rodeo, and the milkshakes do most of the talking.
3 local tips
- The old-fashioned sodas and floats are the point here, so leave room even after a sandwich.
- It keeps daytime hours and is closed midweek, so it is a lunch plan, not a dinner one.
- Soups change daily and sell through, so ask what is left if you arrive late in the lunch run.
A small-batch ice cream shop on Sheridan churning inventive flavors like bourbon maple pecan and white chocolate huckleberry. The line out the door on a summer evening is the local verdict.
3 local tips
- The huckleberry leans into a regional flavor you will not find back home, so try it over a default scoop.
- Flavors rotate, so a return visit rarely repeats the same case.
- It is a walk-up kind of spot, so plan to take your cone strolling down Sheridan.
A longtime community coffeehouse that has been the local hangout for a quarter century, pulling solid espresso alongside breakfast burritos and bagels. It is where Cody actually starts its morning, not a tourist cafe.
3 local tips
- The breakfast burrito is the order regulars get with their coffee, not just a pastry.
- Mornings draw the local crowd, so it is the spot for overhearing what is actually happening in town.
- Seating is limited at peak, so grab a couch early or plan to take it to go.
An old-fashioned breakfast-and-lunch diner doing classic American plates plus a few inventive twists like peach cobbler French toast. Cheap, fast, and unpretentious, it is the local fuel-up before a day on the road to Yellowstone.
3 local tips
- The creative French toast specials are worth straying from the standard eggs-and-hash routine.
- It runs daytime hours only, so it is a breakfast or early-lunch plan.
- Service moves fast, which makes it a good pre-park stop when you have a drive ahead.
An owner-operated pizza-and-sandwich shop run by people with decades in the business, known for signature pies, Philly sandwiches, and a calzone regulars order by name. Counter-casual and built for takeout with a good beer to go alongside.
3 local tips
- The Piggy Smalls calzone is the order locals steer newcomers toward.
- It pairs well with a stop next door for craft beer, so plan it as a casual combo.
- Portions are large, so a couple of sandwiches can feed more people than you would guess.