Sandra D's Italian Garden
italian★ 4.8(201)
Family-run Italian spot that has been hand-making soups, sauces, and pastas since opening in 2001 — the kitchen is famously small, the portions generously oversized. Friday and Saturday nights fill up fast with regulars who come for the lasagna and the genuine warmth of the Dillinger family running the floor.
3 local tips
- Hours are limited — Thursday through Sunday only, lunch through early dinner; plan accordingly rather than assuming it's open.
- The soup changes daily and sells out; arriving before noon on the weekend means you get first pick.
- It's cash-friendly and the wait for a table moves quickly since the room turns over fast.
Bo Doogie's BBQ
american★ 4.5(136)
Serious wood-smoked barbecue out of a no-frills building on the north end of Auburn — brisket, pulled pork, rib tips, and burnt ends done the slow way. The two-meat lunch with two sides is the move for value; locals run out of brisket by mid-afternoon on Saturdays.
3 local tips
- Wednesday through Saturday only; arrive before 1pm on weekends if burnt ends are on your list — they go first.
- Order at the counter, grab napkins in bulk, and pick a table near the window for the best light.
- The hot link sausage is underordered and worth adding to any two-meat combo.
North Main Street Diner
american★ 4.7(265)
Classic diner doing everything right: daily specials chalked on a board, meatloaf and beef-and-noodles that taste like someone's grandma made them, and a vintage atmosphere that doesn't feel staged. Breakfasts run big — the Covered and Smothered hash is a commitment.
3 local tips
- Weekday mornings are the sweet spot — the counter fills with regulars and you'll hear actual Auburn conversation.
- The daily special board is posted on their Facebook page each morning if you want to plan around it.
- Cash is preferred; the ATM is just inside the door.
Shorty's Steakhouse
american★ 4.8(367)
Small-town steakhouse in Garrett that punches well above its price point — the braised short rib and prime rib draw people from Fort Wayne and beyond. Tucked into a downtown storefront with no signage that screams 'restaurant,' which keeps the room surprisingly calm even on weekend evenings.
3 local tips
- Reservations are worth making for Friday and Saturday evenings — the dining room is compact and fills.
- The prime rib sells out; if it's on the board when you arrive, don't second-guess it.
- Garrett is about 10 minutes west on SR-8 — a straightforward drive from central Auburn.
Salsa Grille
mexican★ 4.4(500)
Fast-casual Mexican on Smaltz Way where you build bowls, burritos, tacos, and quesadillas from a made-to-order line — the Auburn outpost of a Fort Wayne-area chain that opened here in November 2023. Everything is customizable and assembled in front of you, which keeps the lunch line moving even when it's busy.
3 local tips
- Order at the counter and customize as you go — burrito bowls and street tacos anchor the menu.
- Open daily including Sunday evenings, one of the later-serving spots on this end of Auburn.
- Located on the Smaltz Way retail strip near other Auburn shops, easy to pair with errands.
The Water's Edge
american★ 4.3(120)
Steak and seafood restaurant inside the Bridgewater Golf Club clubhouse, with a screened patio overlooking the 18th fairway — the view alone earns a visit. Open to the public year-round, not just members, making it the most scenic dinner option within ten miles of downtown Auburn.
3 local tips
- Request a patio table when calling ahead — the indoor dining room is fine but the fairway view is the reason to come.
- The acoustics inside are noted as loud; the patio solves this problem entirely.
- Located on Morningstar Road just northeast of town — plug the Bridgewater Golf Club address into GPS.
Hangar 9 Bar & Grille
american★ 4.4(126)
Neighborhood sports bar with better-than-expected food — the steak tacos are a genuine sleeper hit and the karaoke nights pull a loyal local crowd. Named for its proximity to the Auburn Municipal Airport, it's the kind of place where you can catch a game and have a real conversation at the same bar.
3 local tips
- Steak tacos are the menu's best-kept secret; order those before anything else.
- Karaoke nights run late on weekends and the bar gets loud — arrive early if you want dinner conversation.
- Located on S Wayne St near the auto museum campus, convenient after a museum visit.
Auburn's Town Tavern
american★ 4.2(657)
All-day tavern on S Main that draws the early-morning coffee crowd and the Friday fish fry crowd in equal measure — the beer-battered whitefish is the thing to order. The Fat Boy Tenderloin sandwich is an Indiana staple done correctly: pork pounded thin, breaded golden, and hanging well past the bun.
3 local tips
- The Friday fish fry runs through the evening and is popular enough to cause a wait — show up at opening or after 7.
- Breakfast starts at 6:30am daily, making it one of the earlier options in Auburn.
- The dining room and bar are separate — the bar side is livelier; the dining room is quieter for families.
9th Street Brew Coffee House
cafe★ 4.6(392)
Downtown Auburn's community coffee hub in a brick-walled space that also runs bagels, baked goods, and a full espresso menu — the London fog and dirty chai are consistent regulars. Open early on weekdays and a gathering spot for people who actually live here.
3 local tips
- Saturday hours are shorter (closing at 2pm) and Sunday is closed entirely — factor that into weekend plans.
- The in-house bagels sell out mid-morning; arrive before 9am on weekdays to get first pick.
- Parking is easy on 9th Street; the walk from downtown's Courthouse Square is five minutes.
Kathy's Kountry Kitchen
american★ 4.3(30)
No-frills roadside diner in Waterloo — about 7 miles north of Auburn on US-6 — serving honest home cooking at prices that feel like they're stuck in another decade. Smothered chicken dinner, biscuits and gravy, and daily specials pulled from actual cooking rather than a bag.
3 local tips
- It's a Waterloo institution for the early crowd — farmers and road-trippers both; mornings are the high point.
- The portions run large; the lunch special is often a better value than ordering off the regular menu.
- Located on US Highway 6 — easy to spot from the road heading north toward Waterloo.