Goosefeather
asian★ 4.3(456)
A Michelin-noted Hong Kong-style Cantonese restaurant set inside a beautifully appointed manor house on the grounds of the Tarrytown House Estate. The menu leans into char siu, noodles, and dim sum staples elevated with seasonal touches, and the dining room gives the whole meal an unhurried quality.
3 local tips
- Reserve well in advance; the estate setting makes this a popular special-occasion destination.
- The carved roast meat boards and hand-pulled noodle dishes are the anchors of the menu.
- Outdoor patio seating on the estate grounds is worth requesting in good weather.
Bistro 12
mediterranean★ 4.5(311)
An intimate ten-table room on Main Street where the menu wanders confidently between Portuguese, French, and Italian. Pork with clams in wine sauce sits alongside braised rabbit and grilled octopus on escarole — the tight space and personal service make it feel like a neighborhood spot that happens to cook at a serious level.
3 local tips
- Book ahead for weekends — the room fills fast and there are only about ten tables.
- The Portuguese Alentejana (pork and clams) is the dish locals point visitors toward.
- The beet salad and grilled octopus are reliable starters before moving to the mains.
Sweet Grass Grill
american★ 4.4(380)
A farm-to-table spot in central Tarrytown with a menu that changes weekly based on harvests from a dozen or so regional farms, which keeps regulars coming back to see what's new. Plenty of vegetarian and vegan options alongside meat dishes, with a laid-back atmosphere that works equally well for lunch or a relaxed dinner.
3 local tips
- Check the weekly menu online before going — the rotation is real and dishes you read about may not be there.
- Weekend brunch draws a crowd; a weekday lunch visit is more relaxed.
- The grass-fed burger and vegan options are strong — one of the few places that executes both well.
RiverMarket Bar and Kitchen
american★ 4.3(290)
A West Main Street bar and kitchen with a serious commitment to locally sourced meats, seafood, and produce from the Hudson Valley region. The casual-but-considered room serves lunch and dinner daily, and the bar program is worth sitting at — good cocktails and a thoughtful beer list complement ingredient-focused food without fussiness.
3 local tips
- The bar itself is a great perch for a solo dinner or drinks — locals tend to gather there.
- Fish dishes rotate with what's fresh from Long Island Sound; ask what came in recently.
- Parking on West Main Street can be tight on weekends; the municipal lot nearby is easier.
Horsefeathers
american★ 4.2(520)
A Tarrytown pub institution that has been feeding regulars since 1981, with a menu of burgers, salads, sandwiches, and hearty mains that knows exactly what it is. The cozy interior with its pub tables and sidewalk seating in season draws a mix of longtime locals and visitors who want a no-pretense meal with a cold beer.
3 local tips
- One of the few places that works equally well for lunch, an early dinner, or a late-night bite.
- The burger and sandwiches are the stalwarts — straightforward and reliably done.
- Sidewalk seating on Broadway is a prime people-watching spot on warm evenings.
Bridge View Tavern
american★ 4.4(310)
A Sleepy Hollow tavern and beer garden on Beekman Avenue with Hudson River views and a menu that elevates pub staples with genuine culinary care. The outdoor beer garden is one of the more scenic spots to eat in the area, especially when the light on the water is good.
3 local tips
- The beer garden is the main draw — come when the weather cooperates.
- Request a table with river views when booking; not all seats share the same outlook.
- Food quality goes beyond what the tavern setting suggests — worth ordering properly rather than just snacking.
Mint Premium Foods
mediterranean★ 4.4(210)
A small Tarrytown market-cafe hybrid that bridges the gap between specialty grocer and sit-down Mediterranean spot — good for picking up provisions or settling in for a mezze spread. The prepared foods, cheeses, and small plates make it an easy stop before exploring the area.
3 local tips
- Doubles as a gourmet grocery — worth grabbing provisions here for a picnic at Kingsland Point Park.
- The prepared Mediterranean platters and cheese selections travel well.
- Goes quickly on weekend mornings; earlier arrival means better selection.
Taqueria La Perla Poblanita
mexican★ 4.4(175)
An authentic Mexican taqueria on Main Street serving huaraches, sopes, burritos, and fajitas that draw a loyal local following well beyond the immediate neighborhood. The kind of place where the food speaks for itself in a no-frills setting, and locals know it.
3 local tips
- The huaraches and sopes are the standouts and rarely appear on menus like this in the area.
- Cash is preferred; confirm payment options before ordering.
- Weekday lunches are the least crowded time to go.
Santorini Greek Restaurant
mediterranean★ 4.3(195)
A Sleepy Hollow Greek restaurant with a menu of cold and hot mezze, salads, and traditional mains that goes deeper than the typical gyro-and-spanakopita format. The unpretentious room and consistent kitchen have made it a neighborhood anchor for years.
3 local tips
- Start with a spread of cold appetizers — the variety makes it easy to share across the table.
- The seafood dishes hold up alongside the meat-heavy classics.
- Easier to get a table here on weekdays when Tarrytown spots fill up.
Ilios Greek Taverna & Bar
mediterranean★ 4.2(220)
A lively Greek taverna on Tarrytown's main strip with a menu that covers the full range from saganaki and dolmades to grilled fish and lamb in a warm, convivial atmosphere. The bar side keeps things going into the evening for locals looking to extend dinner into drinks.
3 local tips
- The saganaki and grilled octopus are good opening moves.
- Bar seating works well for solo diners or couples who want to keep things casual.
- Weekends get festive; come prepared for a livelier atmosphere than a quiet dinner.
JP Doyle's
american★ 4.3(245)
A Sleepy Hollow neighborhood pub with a menu that ranges from pub classics to more inventive plates — burgers, fish and chips, and satisfying mains in a welcoming, unpretentious room that makes it feel like a proper local rather than a destination spot.
3 local tips
- Works for a relaxed weeknight dinner when you don't want to deal with Tarrytown weekend crowds.
- The fish and chips are well-regarded by regulars.
- The bar side is a good spot to meet locals if you're staying in the area.
Joah Kitchen
american★ 4.3(130)
A Tarrytown kitchen with a menu of thoughtfully assembled American plates that rewards exploration. The kitchen takes local sourcing seriously, and the room has an energy that distinguishes it from the established spots without trying too hard.
3 local tips
- Worth checking their specials board — the daily additions often reflect what came in fresh.
- The room is compact; reservations are recommended for dinner.
- Lunch service is a lower-key entry point than the dinner crowd.
Pita House
middle_eastern★ 4.3(160)
A quick-service Middle Eastern spot on Tarrytown's main strip with falafel, shawarma, and well-constructed pitas that locals rely on for fast, filling, no-fuss meals. The quality punches well above the price and format, making it a reliable lunch stop before heading to the historic sites.
3 local tips
- The falafel wrap is the anchor order; add the tahini-heavy sauces.
- Counter service and quick turnaround make it ideal before a full day of sightseeing.
- A consistent go-to when other options have waits.
Sleepy Coffee Too
cafe★ 4.5(145)
A community-rooted non-profit cafe in Sleepy Hollow serving certified organic fair-trade coffee alongside from-scratch baked goods made daily — banana bread, cookies, and blueberry almond croissants. The mission-driven operation employs adults with disabilities, and the coffee is genuinely good on its own merits.
3 local tips
- The banana bread and blueberry almond croissant are the baked goods to seek out.
- A good starting point before a morning walk through Sleepy Hollow Cemetery.
- The organic coffee quality stands on its own merits beyond the worthwhile mission.
Mes Amis French Cafe
cafe★ 4.3(115)
A French-inflected cafe on the Tarrytown strip with proper espresso drinks, pastries, and light cafe fare in a room that feels more Paris-adjacent than Westchester. A natural spot for a mid-morning pause when moving between the Hudson Valley sights.
3 local tips
- The morning pastry selection goes fast; earlier visits get the best spread.
- Works equally well for coffee and a croissant or a light lunch.
- Quieter on weekday mornings than the weekend rush.