Sarah Street Grill
american★ 4.2(505)
A downtown Stroudsburg anchor that covers sushi, burgers, steaks, and craft cocktails in a lively room with live music most nights. More than 30 years in operation means the kitchen has found its footing on a wide menu that doesn't try to be everything at once. The sushi is better than you'd expect from a grill-forward menu.
2 local tips
- Live music starts mid-evening most nights; come earlier if you want a quieter dinner, later if you want the energy of the room.
- The sushi menu is a genuine part of the kitchen's identity, not an afterthought — it's worth ordering from if you're sitting at the bar.
Siamsa Irish Pub
american★ 4.3(310)
An Irish pub on Main Street Stroudsburg with a proper whiskey program, consistent Irish-American kitchen, and the feel of a local regular spot rather than a tourist destination. The fish and chips are exactly what they should be; the whiskey list is the kind of thing that rewards spending time with the menu.
2 local tips
- The whiskey selection is the strongest part of the bar program — ask the staff for recommendations on Irish expressions you might not know.
- The kitchen stays open later than most Stroudsburg restaurants, which makes it a reliable option on evenings when other spots have stopped taking orders.
Farmhouse Eatery Crystal Street
brunch★ 4.4(194)
A farm-to-table scratch kitchen in East Stroudsburg doing all-day brunch and craft cocktails with a menu that covers both vegan and comfort-food ground. The space is small and warm; the cooking takes its sourcing seriously in a way that stands out in the Poconos dining landscape.
2 local tips
- The all-day brunch menu is stronger than the dinner service — morning and midday are when the kitchen is at its best.
- Waits can develop on weekend mornings; call ahead or check wait times before making the drive.
Fabu Restaurant & Catering
american★ 4.5(200)
A Caribbean restaurant in East Stroudsburg bringing authentic preparations to a region that otherwise lacks them — the curried chicken and stewed goat are the standout dishes, tender and properly seasoned. The service is warm and the room is informal; the food is the entire reason to seek this one out.
2 local tips
- The stewed goat and curried chicken are the dishes locals bring out-of-town guests to try — order those before looking at anything else.
- Portions are generous; a party of two can usually get away with two entrees and a side rather than ordering separately per person.
Trackside Station Grill & Bar
american★ 4.3(250)
A pub and grill in East Stroudsburg that covers the reliable end of the Poconos dining spectrum — solid burgers, classic bar fare, and a sports-friendly room that's comfortable for groups of varying appetites. The service earns consistent praise; the food is satisfying without trying to be ambitious.
2 local tips
- The bar side is livelier on game nights; the dining room offers a quieter option for families.
- Good fallback option when higher-effort dining requires a longer wait or reservation.
Bluefoot Cuisine
american★ 4.4(180)
An East Stroudsburg restaurant with a Latin-inflected menu that covers empanadas, well-prepared seafood, and dishes that don't fit neatly into the standard Poconos restaurant category. The cheese guava empanadas are the signature starter; the pan-seared salmon is the dinner standard-bearer.
2 local tips
- Start with the empanadas regardless of what you plan to order for the main course.
- The room fills on weekend evenings; reservations or early arrival are worth the effort.
Tom X Pub
american★ 4.3(200)
A Stroudsburg pub that's been in the neighborhood long enough to feel genuinely local rather than visitor-facing — good sandwiches, reliable draft list, and a room that's comfortable for a long afternoon on a hiking day. The outdoor space is the main draw in warm months.
2 local tips
- The outdoor area is first-come on weekends; weekend afternoon hikers returning from Delaware Water Gap often end up here.
- Simple food done without pretension; come for a post-hike beer rather than a special-occasion meal.
Pocono Brewing Company
american★ 4.4(250)
A local craft brewery in the Mount Pocono area with a rotating tap list of house-brewed beers and a kitchen that goes beyond brewery-standard food. The taproom has an outdoor deck with mountain views, making it the best outdoor drinking spot in the Mount Pocono area.
2 local tips
- The outdoor deck is the main reason to come in warm months; arrive in early afternoon on weekends before it fills.
- The seasonal and small-batch releases are the most interesting part of the tap list; ask what's rotating before ordering.
Callie's Candy Kitchen
dessert★ 4.5(600)
A Pocono candy institution that's been making hand-crafted chocolates and candies at the same Mountainhome location for over 70 years. The fudge, chocolate-covered pretzels, and seasonal candy are made on-site; the store is more production facility than gift shop, and watching the candy being made is part of the visit.
2 local tips
- The factory viewing window lets you watch candy production in process — worth timing your visit to see the chocolate-dipping operation.
- The irregular-shaped 'seconds' chocolates at the counter are the same quality as the packaged items at a lower price.
Dimmick Inn
american★ 4.3(300)
A historic inn and restaurant in Milford that's been serving the upper Poconos since the 19th century — the building is as much the reason to go as the food, and the menu is reliable American comfort food that pairs well with the room's age and character. Good for a proper dinner on an evening when you've been outdoors all day.
2 local tips
- The bar in the original 19th-century inn section is the best place to sit — it's more atmospheric than the dining room extension.
- Milford itself is worth an hour of walking after dinner; the historic downtown has some of the most intact Victorian-era streetscapes in the Poconos.
Craft & Draft Stroudsburg
american★ 4.3(150)
A newer downtown Stroudsburg bar and kitchen with a strong local craft beer selection and a food menu that covers the pub-food essentials without padding. One of the better arguments for a Stroudsburg evening that starts with dinner and transitions into a drinking stop.
2 local tips
- The local and regional tap selections change frequently — ask what's new from Pennsylvania breweries.
- The kitchen tends to be more consistent on weeknights; weekend evenings can be busier than the small space comfortably handles.