El Toro Loco
mexican★ 4.6(149)
A Mexican restaurant in a beautifully renovated downtown building with murals on the walls — the visual standout among Metropolis's limited dining options. The food is authentic and well-executed: tamales, tacos, and hearty soups that go beyond the Americanized Mexican menu most rural Illinois towns offer. It's the local sleeper hit that reviews consistently single out.
3 local tips
- The mural work on the interior walls is worth a look before you order — a genuine effort at making the space feel different.
- The combination plates are the best value; the tamales specifically get consistent praise in reviews.
- Lunch hours are quieter than dinner; the kitchen moves faster in the early afternoon.
Cordavino's
italian★ 4.4(389)
The most upscale sit-down option in downtown Metropolis — an Italian restaurant serving pasta, pizza, and steak on the same Ferry Street block as the more casual local options. The room is proper and the service is attentive, which makes it the obvious choice for a dinner that feels like a deliberate occasion rather than a quick meal. The price point is modest by any metro standard.
3 local tips
- Reservations are a good idea on weekend evenings; the room is small and fills with locals celebrating.
- The pasta dishes are the kitchen's strength — the pizza is solid but the pasta is where the effort shows.
- Ferry Street has multiple dining options within a one-block walk; plan a pre-dinner drink at a neighboring spot.
Fat Edd's Roadhouse
american★ 4.3(520)
The local institution on Ferry Street — a straightforward, no-attitude roadhouse with burgers, fried fish baskets, and sweet tea that draws regulars over and over. The 1-piece fish basket is the thing most people order when they know what they're doing. The atmosphere is as unpretentious as small-town southern Illinois gets, and the staff are genuinely friendly rather than performatively so.
3 local tips
- The 1-piece fried fish basket is the local go-to; ask what came in fresh that day before defaulting to the menu description.
- Sweet tea is properly sweetened here — ask for unsweetened if that's your preference.
- Park on Ferry Street rather than searching for a lot; it's a short walk from anywhere in downtown.
Strickland's Seafood Restaurant
seafood★ 4.3(234)
A seafood-forward restaurant in Metropolis that has built a loyal following for its consistent quality and Ohio River town authenticity. The review count — substantial for a town this size — reflects repeat business rather than tourist surge. Fried catfish and shrimp are the draws; the room is relaxed and the portions honest.
3 local tips
- The catfish is the benchmark dish — it's the one item that local reviews consistently single out.
- Arrives early for dinner; the kitchen paces differently than a city restaurant.
- Good combination for a Superman Celebration weekend when you want a proper meal rather than festival food.
Bridges Dining Company
american★ 4.2(180)
The most polished restaurant in the metro area, inside Harrah's hotel on the Ohio River with a steakhouse-plus-breakfast format. The Sunday brunch with build-your-own omelets draws a local crowd who dress slightly for it; the dinner menu runs to seafood and steak at prices that feel appropriate for the river views. Open Thursday through Sunday only.
3 local tips
- Thursday through Sunday operation only — confirm before planning a weekday dinner.
- Sunday brunch is the best time to come; the locals who use this as their special-occasion spot make it feel less like a hotel restaurant.
- The river views from the dining room are the best in Metropolis — request a window table.
Yesterday's BBQ
american★ 4.3(130)
A small BBQ and home-cooking spot on West 10th Street that locals treat as a cultural institution despite its modest size. The Superman breakfast — a novelty on the menu — gets its photo taken almost as much as the statue downtown. The real draw is straightforward BBQ and home-cooked plates at prices that haven't caught up to the restaurant's reputation.
3 local tips
- The Superman breakfast is a fun order if you're in town for the Superman angle — worth the novelty.
- Home-cooked plate specials rotate daily; ask what's on rather than defaulting to the printed menu.
- The space is small — weekday lunch is the most comfortable visit window.