Coppermill Steakhouse
american★ 4.3(210)
The dress-up steakhouse of southwest Nebraska, plating aged steaks, seafood and pasta alongside the largest wine list for miles. It is the special-occasion room in town, a notch above the casual spots. The choice for a serious dinner.
3 local tips
- Aged steaks are the centerpiece; the wine list is unusually deep for the region
- It is the area's special-occasion table, so reserve on weekends
- Seafood and pasta round out the menu for non-steak eaters
The Axe House
american★ 4.2(180)
A downtown bar and grill on Norris Avenue pairing burgers, sandwiches and drinks with lanes for axe throwing. It is the casual spot where dinner doubles as entertainment, good for a group looking for a fun night. Easygoing and a little different.
3 local tips
- Book a lane if you want to throw axes; the kitchen does burgers and bar fare alongside
- It is a fun group spot, livelier than the sit-down rooms
- Central on Norris Avenue, easy to combine with a downtown evening
El Puerto
mexican★ 4.3(160)
An authentic Mexican restaurant turning out generous, well-prepared plates at fair prices, a local favorite. It is the dependable, casual spot for Mexican food in town. Friendly and filling.
3 local tips
- Portions are generous and prices fair, good value for a casual meal
- The margaritas pair well with the combo plates
- Casual and welcoming to families
Bison Cafe
american★ 4.1(95)
A casual cafe built around 100% grass-fed bison and from-scratch pizza, a only-here pairing in downtown McCook. It is the spot to eat the plains' native meat in burger form alongside a hand-made pie. Wholesome, local and a little unexpected.
3 local tips
- The grass-fed bison burger is the signature; the scratch pizza is the other draw
- It is casual and good for a relaxed lunch or dinner
- A local, wholesome alternative to the steakhouse
Citta's Deli & Restaurant
italian★ 4.2(130)
A downtown deli and restaurant doing Italian-leaning plates, sandwiches and pasta in a relaxed room. It is the easy, casual option for a lighter meal away from the steakhouses. Friendly and dependable.
3 local tips
- The deli sandwiches and pasta are the strengths for a casual meal
- Good for a lighter lunch between sights
- Central downtown, easy to find
Joltin Jo's Espresso
cafe★ 4.4(85)
A downtown coffee shop pouring espresso, smoothies and frappes alongside home-baked goodies. It is the morning fuel stop and afternoon pause in town, warm and welcoming. The easy daytime anchor on the avenue.
3 local tips
- The home-baked goodies pair well with the espresso drinks
- Good for a morning start or an afternoon pick-me-up
- Central downtown, an easy walk-in