Wolf Creek Bar & Grille
american★ 4.4(312)
A Main Street institution known for its ribs and hand-cut steaks — the dining room is warm-toned wood with a fireplace, and the bar keeps a focused whiskey selection. Portions are sized for people who have been hiking, and the kitchen doesn't overthink the proteins.
3 local tips
- The half-rack of ribs is the right order for one person; the full rack is honestly two meals.
- Bar seating is first-come and has shorter waits than the dining room on busy summer weekends.
- Ask about off-menu specials before ordering — the kitchen often runs seasonal game or local trout that doesn't appear on the printed menu.
The Ugly Dog Pub
american★ 4.3(287)
Highlands' casual pub anchor on Main — covered deck, pint list leaning toward craft regionals, and a bar menu that covers burgers, wings, and loaded nachos without pretense. The outdoor seating fills faster than the interior on cool evenings, and the crowd mixes locals with summer visitors seamlessly.
3 local tips
- The deck is covered and heated with propane lamps on cool nights — don't assume it's seasonal.
- Happy hour runs weekday afternoons and includes bar bites at reduced prices; the timing isn't posted prominently so ask when you sit down.
- Parking behind Main Street is easier than the front strip on peak summer weekends.
Madison's Restaurant
american★ 4.6(418)
The dining room inside Old Edwards Inn — white tablecloth service, Southern-influenced contemporary plates, and a wine list built for the clientele that books the inn. Local sourcing is genuine rather than decorative, and the kitchen applies real technique to familiar regional ingredients.
3 local tips
- Request a table in the main dining room rather than the side addition — the original room has better proportions and quieter acoustics.
- The Sunday brunch is less expensive than dinner and uses the same kitchen; a useful entry point if dinner prices feel steep.
- Reservations are essential in summer, often 5-7 days out; the inn's concierge can sometimes pull a table that doesn't show online.
Central House Restaurant
american★ 4.3(195)
One of the oldest operating restaurants in Highlands, with a reputation for straightforward Southern home cooking — country ham, biscuits, and seasonal vegetables done without elaboration. The lunch service is the busiest, drawing a mix of residents and day visitors who want a real meal.
3 local tips
- The breakfast and lunch windows are the right times to visit — dinner is quieter but the menu changes less.
- Seating fills fast on rainy summer days when outdoor activities are off the table; arrive early or expect a wait.
- The daily specials board reflects what came in fresh; it's worth asking what's on it before defaulting to the printed menu.
Fressers Fine Foods
cafe★ 4.5(163)
A gourmet provisions shop and café on Main that sells prepared foods, artisan cheeses, charcuterie, and specialty grocery alongside a café counter for espresso and light breakfast. Popular as a picnic assembler before a waterfall hike or a quick stop for people who are self-catering in a rental.
3 local tips
- The prepared foods case changes daily — check early in the morning for the best selection before it sells through.
- They carry a curated wine selection well above what the grocery stores in the area stock; worth a browse if you're stocking a rental.
- The café counter gets busy around 8-9 a.m.; ordering ahead or arriving at opening avoids the wait.
Oak & Vine
american★ 4.5(234)
A wine-forward small-plates restaurant that fills the upscale-casual gap in Highlands' dining scene — the list skews toward European producers and the food is built around cheese, charcuterie, and small composed plates that pair with wine rather than competing with it. A good option when you want to drink well without committing to a full tasting-menu format.
3 local tips
- The cheese selection rotates; ask the server what's in best condition that night rather than ordering from the menu blind.
- Small plates genuinely are small — two to three per person is closer to accurate than one.
- The bar seats at the wine station have better sightlines to the room and sometimes come free before the dining room fills.
Lakeside Restaurant
american★ 4.5(389)
A long-standing Highlands institution on Smallwood Avenue with a deck overlooking a private lake — the kitchen does New American plates with an emphasis on local trout and seasonal produce. The view is the context for everything, and it works best at sunset when the lake surface catches the evening light.
3 local tips
- Reserve a deck table specifically — the interior dining room faces the same view but through glass and feels less connected.
- The trout, sourced from nearby mountain streams, is the right order regardless of what else looks good that night.
- Dinner-only format; no lunch service, and the kitchen closes earlier than city restaurants so don't push arrival past 7:30 p.m.
Nick's Mountain Grille
american★ 4.3(241)
A Main Street grill with a following for its hand-pressed burgers, beer-battered fish, and an unpretentious bar that draws a mixed crowd of second-home owners and service industry locals after-hours. The room is straightforward and the food delivers without fuss.
3 local tips
- The burger selection changes; the double with local cheese is the standard order that doesn't disappoint.
- Bar service at Nick's is notably faster than the dining room on busy nights — seat yourself there if you want to eat without a long wait.
- Outdoor seating is limited and first-come; go early on summer evenings if sitting outside matters to you.
On the Verandah Restaurant
american★ 4.6(476)
A candlelit restaurant with wrap-around verandah seating above a creek — seasonal menus lean Southern contemporary with local sourcing, and the setting is the most romantic in Highlands proper. The kitchen has been consistent for decades and the service matches the room's ambition.
3 local tips
- The creek-side verandah tables book first; specify them when reserving and call rather than booking online if the site doesn't let you note a preference.
- The prix-fixe option is usually the better value than ordering à la carte when it's available.
- Service is deliberate rather than rushed — this is not the right pick if you have tickets to an evening show.
Highlands' long-running Chinese and Asian fusion restaurant — a reliable option for nights when mountain Southern fare isn't what the table wants, with a menu spanning Sichuan-influenced dishes and broader pan-Asian plates. The lunch specials are the best value on the menu.
3 local tips
- The spice levels on Sichuan dishes can be requested authentically hot — the kitchen will dial it back by default for the local clientele unless you specify.
- Lunch prix-fixe includes soup, entree, and rice at a price that undercuts everything else in town.
- Takeout is efficient and the packaging holds well — a reasonable option if your rental has a table worth eating at.
Paoletti's Restaurant
italian★ 4.4(352)
A Main Street Italian that has anchored Highlands dining since 1983 — handmade pastas, wood-fired dishes, and an Italian wine list that holds its own. The room is warm and densely set; the kitchen stays consistent across the full menu rather than excelling at one category.
3 local tips
- The pasta is made in-house daily and is the reason to come; the protein dishes are competent but less distinctive.
- Request a booth when reserving — the tables in the center of the room are noisier when the room fills.
- The wine list has good value in the under-$60 range if you know what you're looking for; ask the server to point to Italian regions rather than specific labels.
The Ruffed Grouse Tavern
american★ 4.4(203)
A tavern inside Old Edwards Inn with a more relaxed format than Madison's — the menu covers shareable small plates, elevated bar food, and a focused cocktail program that draws from local botanicals and Appalachian spirits. A better fit for late arrivals or groups that want to graze rather than sit for a formal dinner.
3 local tips
- The cocktail program uses regional whiskeys and shrubs that you won't find assembled this way elsewhere in the area; worth exploring even if you're not a serious cocktail drinker.
- The kitchen at the tavern stays open later than most Highlands restaurants, which matters when you drive in after 8 p.m.
- Sharing plates between two to four people works well here — the format is designed for it.
The Kelsey Place Restaurant
american★ 4.3(187)
A family-friendly American restaurant in Cashiers serving straightforward steaks, salads, and comfort plates in a room that has been feeding the plateau's visitors for years. The kitchen doesn't deviate from its strengths, and the value relative to Highlands' upscale dining scene is worth the 12-minute drive east.
3 local tips
- Cashiers sits at a similar elevation but tends to have shorter restaurant waits on peak summer weekends when Highlands proper is overwhelmed.
- The onion rings and fried sides are better than the menu description suggests — worth ordering as a starter.
- Parking in Cashiers is straightforward compared to Main Street Highlands; a real advantage when you have a group.