Fenicci's of Hershey
italian★ 4.5(1,840)
A downtown Hershey Italian restaurant that has been feeding the town and its visitors since 1935, making it the oldest restaurant in Hershey and possibly its most beloved. The menu covers house-made pastas, classic Italian-American dishes, and a long list of daily specials in a warm, family-run room that radiates the comfort of a place that knows exactly what it is.
2 local tips
- Reservations are important on summer weekends when Hersheypark crowds fill the dining rooms.
- The daily specials are where the kitchen's best work shows — ask about them before ordering from the printed menu.
Hershey Pantry
brunch★ 4.5(1,520)
A beloved breakfast and lunch spot on Chocolate Avenue that has been the preferred morning destination for locals and savvy visitors for decades. The menu covers eggs, pancakes, French toast, and house-baked goods in generous portions that consistently outperform any hotel breakfast option in the area.
2 local tips
- Expect a wait on weekend mornings — it's genuinely popular with the local crowd, not just tourists.
- The baked goods and sticky buns are made in-house; arrive by 8 a.m. for the full selection.
Chocolate Avenue Grill
american★ 4.3(1,020)
A downtown Hershey grill offering New American dishes in a comfortable setting that manages to feel local rather than tourist-targeted. The menu covers a range from burgers and sandwiches to more composed dinner plates, and the kitchen uses local ingredients with genuine care. One of the more reliable spots on Chocolate Avenue for an actual good meal.
2 local tips
- The outdoor patio seating is pleasant for an evening meal in warm weather.
- More reliable for dinner than lunch — the kitchen has more time to show its range in the evening.
Devon Seafood & Steak
seafood★ 4.4(960)
Located in the historic Hershey Press Building in downtown Hershey, Devon offers fresh seafood sourced daily alongside prime steaks and an award-winning wine list in a setting that feels genuinely upscale without the corporate polish of a chain steakhouse. The crab-stuffed trout and Chesapeake Bay preparations are particular strengths.
2 local tips
- The raw bar is the place to start — oysters and shrimp cocktail are reliably fresh.
- Reservations are essential for dinner; walk-ins can sometimes find bar seating.
Piazza Sorrento
italian★ 4.4(780)
A modern Italian restaurant in downtown Hershey drawing on Old World recipes with a contemporary presentation. The kitchen produces its own pasta and takes the Neapolitan pizza tradition seriously, with a wood-fired approach to both that distinguishes it from the standard Italian-American options in the area.
2 local tips
- The wood-fired pizza is better than most visitors expect — worth ordering even as a side to a pasta meal.
- BYOB policy on certain nights — confirm when booking.
Hotel Hershey Circular Dining Room
american★ 4.5(1,240)
The grand dining room of Milton Hershey's 1933 hotel, with a circular layout, panoramic windows overlooking the gardens, and a formal Pennsylvania farm-to-table menu. Sunday brunch here — with an extravagant spread and a dessert cart that includes chocolate preparations — is one of the most celebratory meals in the Harrisburg region.
2 local tips
- Sunday brunch reservations book out weeks ahead — call well in advance.
- Smart casual dress is expected; the formal dress code is relaxed from historical standards but avoid athletic wear.
Rotunda Brew Pub
american★ 4.3(680)
A craft brewery and pub in the Hershey area with a rotating selection of house-brewed beers alongside a menu that covers burgers, sandwiches, and bar staples executed with more care than the setting suggests. A good option when you want a local craft beer and a proper burger without the formality of the hotel restaurants.
2 local tips
- The seasonal and limited releases move quickly — ask the bartender what's new before looking at the standard tap list.
- Burger is the dependable order; try it with whatever house IPA is currently on tap.
Harvest Restaurant at Hotel Hershey
american★ 4.3(540)
The more casual of the Hotel Hershey's dining rooms, with a Pennsylvania-focused farm-to-table menu served in a lighter, less formal setting than the Circular Dining Room. Good for a dinner that still draws on local ingredients and the hotel's standards without the full ceremony of the grand dining experience.
2 local tips
- Easier to get into than the Circular Dining Room but still benefits from a reservation in peak season.
- The cocktail program here is well-developed — worth starting with a drink at the adjacent bar.
The Mill at Hershey
american★ 4.2(420)
A pub and restaurant near the Milton Hershey School grounds offering a comfortable neighborhood atmosphere with American comfort food — steaks, burgers, sandwiches, and a solid beer selection. The kind of unpretentious local spot that provides relief from the tourist restaurant circuit on Chocolate Avenue.
2 local tips
- The patio is quieter and more relaxed than the main dining room on busy summer evenings.
- Local Penn State and Harrisburg sports coverage on the TVs makes this a reliable game-watching spot.
Tröegs Independent Brewing Pub
american★ 4.7(3,200)
Hershey's most celebrated brewery — Tröegs produces some of the best craft beer in Pennsylvania, from their flagship Troegenator doppelbock and Perpetual IPA to an ever-rotating line of seasonal and barrel-aged releases. The brewery pub serves food that's calibrated to beer pairing rather than just filler, and the tasting room has the energy of a place that takes its product seriously.
3 local tips
- The barrel-aged releases sell out quickly; arriving on release day requires knowing the schedule in advance.
- The snack foods are designed to pair with specific beers — ask the bar staff for pairings.
- Tours of the brewing facility run on a set schedule and are worth taking if you're genuinely interested in craft brewing.
Lebbie Lebkicher's Restaurant at Hotel Hershey
american★ 4.2(380)
A casual poolside restaurant and bar at Hotel Hershey named for Milton Hershey's personal assistant, who was among his most loyal and longest-serving employees. The menu is lighter and more casual than the hotel's formal dining rooms — salads, sandwiches, and outdoor plates suited to a warm afternoon by the pool.
2 local tips
- Pool access is for hotel guests; non-guests can use the restaurant and bar area adjacent to the pool.
- Best visited on a warm afternoon when indoor dining feels too heavy.
Molly's Courtyard Pub
american★ 4.2(480)
A downtown Hershey Irish-American pub with a comfortable bar, outdoor courtyard seating, and pub food that covers the expected range reliably — fish and chips, shepherd's pie, burgers, and a decent selection of beers on draft. A straightforward option when you want a beer and a reliable meal in a relaxed setting.
2 local tips
- The courtyard fills on warm evenings — arrive early for outdoor seating.
- Live music on weekend evenings is typically acoustic and serves the pub atmosphere well.