Merkin Vineyards Osteria
italian
The Old Town osteria and tasting room of musician-turned-winemaker Maynard James Keenan, doing farm-to-table Italian with house-milled Arizona-grain pasta and breads, paired with the valley's high-elevation wines. The most serious food-and-wine experience in Cottonwood.
2 local tips
- Much of the produce and grain comes from the owner's nearby farm; ask what's local that day.
- Pair the handmade pasta with a flight of the estate wines; it's the whole point of coming.
Naples-certified wood-fired pizza in a transformed 1920s auto shop, where the chef trained in Italy turns out a dozen blistered pies on a daily-changing roster. Industrial-modern room, a bocce court out back, and the best pizza in the valley.
2 local tips
- The daily specials use local produce and go beyond the menu board; ask what's on.
- Play a round on the bocce court out back while you wait for a table on a busy night.
Nic's Italian Steak & Crab House
seafood
A polished old-school steak-and-seafood room with dark woods, brass, and a 40-foot mahogany bar that feels transplanted from an East Coast supper club. The white-tablecloth special-occasion choice in Old Town for steaks, crab, and martinis.
2 local tips
- It's the dress-up dinner in town; the steaks and the crab are the headline, and the bar is a destination itself.
- Reserve on weekends, when the small dining room fills.
A casual American gastropub in a historic Old Town building, doing burgers, sandwiches, and hearty entrees alongside an unusually deep list of Arizona wines. The reliable, all-ages, watch-the-game anchor in the middle of the wine crawl.
2 local tips
- The Arizona wine list is bigger than the casual vibe suggests; it's a low-key way to sample local bottles.
- It's the easy fallback when the fancier rooms are booked, with something for everyone.
Crema Craft Kitchen & Bar
brunch
A laid-back breakfast-and-lunch spot in two prohibition-era buildings with a courtyard, doing a tight scratch menu plus house gelato, espresso, and craft beer. The Old Town morning anchor and the daytime hang.
2 local tips
- It's breakfast and lunch only; come in the morning and don't plan on dinner here.
- The walk-up window serves gelato and coffee in the early afternoon after the kitchen winds down.
Ay, Chihuahua! Mexican Food
mexican
A small, family-run Old Town spot that's become the local favorite for authentic Mexican, with well-balanced salsas and friendly counter service at honest prices. The unfussy taco-and-enchilada fix among all the tasting rooms.
2 local tips
- Salsas are made in-house and worth asking for an extra side of.
- It's small and popular at lunch; an off-peak visit gets you a quieter table.
Bing's Burger Station
american
A burger joint in a restored 1930s Texaco gas station packed with vintage signs and memorabilia, griddling classic burgers, shakes, and fries. A fun, retro, family stop in Old Town that the kids will remember.
2 local tips
- It's as much a roadside-Americana museum as a diner; let the kids wander the memorabilia.
- Burgers and hand-spun shakes are the order; it's casual counter service.
Old Town Red Rooster Cafe
cafe
A homey Old Town cafe doing coffee, breakfast, and lunch in a cozy historic room, the easygoing spot to caffeinate and read before the shops open. Friendly, unpretentious, and properly local.
2 local tips
- Good early-morning coffee-and-pastry stop before the tasting rooms open for the day.
- It's small and calm; a fine place to sit a while away from the busier brunch spots.